After canceled lecture, free speech debate roils science academia

Asia's Tech News Daily

Some academics are pushing back against what they see as personal politics overshadowing scientific work. Others stress that actions have consequences.

A prominent climate physicist resigned Monday from one of his roles at the University of California, Berkeley, after he said faculty members would not agree to invite a guest lecturer to the school who had previously come under fire for his political views.

The lecturer, geophysicist Dorian Abbot, has been the subject of criticism for opposing affirmative action programs and other initiatives designed to promote diversity, equity and inclusion at universities. Abbot has been the subject of boycotts and opposition from left-leaning students and academic faculty meetings.

In a statement on Twitter, the Berkeley physicist, David Romps, said he is stepping down as director of the Berkeley Atmospheric Sciences Center, “at the end of this calendar year or when a replacement is ready, whichever is sooner.” Romps will remain a professor in the school’s department of earth and planetary sciences, according to a Berkeley spokesperson.

The incident has added to an ongoing debate about when, if ever, it is appropriate to suppress speech on college campuses.

Earlier this month, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology rescinded a lecture invitation to Abbot, a geophysicist and associate professor at the University of Chicago, amid public backlash over an op-ed article that he co-wrote in Newsweek that argued in favor of a “Merit, Fairness, and Equality” framework on campuses as an alternative to diversity, equity and inclusion efforts, which he said sought “to increase the representation of some groups through discrimination against members of other groups.” Last year, Abbot also denounced riots that erupted in Chicago after George Floyd was killed by Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin. He addressed those comments in a post published Oct. 5 on Substack.

Abbot was scheduled to deliver the prestigious Carlson Lecture at MIT’s Department of Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences about his research on climate science and the potential for alien planets to support life.

Romps, who did not respond to a request for comment, said his request to Berkeley faculty followed the MIT cancellation.

Romps said he asked faculty members if the school could invite Abbot “to speak to us in the coming months to hear the science talk he had prepared and, by extending the invitation now, reaffirm that BASC is a purely scientific organization, not a political one,” he wrote on Twitter.

The climate scientist said discussions remained unresolved and that his colleagues’ unwillingness to include guest lecturers who have divergent political beliefs goes against the school’s mission.

“Excluding people because of their political and social views diminishes the pool of scientists with which members of BASC can interact and reduces the opportunities for learning and collaboration,” he wrote, adding that such actions signal that, “some opinions — even well-intentioned ones — are forbidden, thereby increasing self-censorship, degrading public discourse, and contributing to our nation’s political balkanization.”

Abbot said in an emailed statement: “Professor Romps is an extremely brave proponent of academic freedom. There are very few people willing to openly defend academic freedom, let alone resign an important directorship in support of it. If we had a few more leaders and administrators like Professor Romps, we wouldn’t be having a crisis of academic freedom in our universities.”

Dan Mogulof, a spokesperson at UC Berkeley, said the school believes that diversity of perspective is “absolutely essential.”

“UC Berkeley’s administration regrets that the director of the Berkeley Atmospheric Sciences Center has decided to resign given that faculty members affiliated with the Center have not yet fully discussed and considered — much less decided — whether to extend an invitation to the speaker in question,” Mogulof said in a statement to NBC News.

Keith Whittington, a professor of politics at Princeton University and chair of the academic committee of the Academic Freedom Alliance, said decisions to shy away from lecture topics or figures who represent opposing viewpoints or have controversial personal politics risk compromising the principles of free speech that universities are meant to uphold.

“That could shrink the scope quite dramatically of what kinds of ideas and opinions can be discussed on college campuses,” he said.

But equating the cancellation of a school’s public lecture to censorship oversimplifies the matter, said Phoebe Cohen, a paleontologist and associate professor of geosciences at Williams College. She added that concerns over whether these types of actions curtail free speech on campuses are overblown.

“It becomes this battle cry of free speech and academic freedom, but he has academic freedom,” Cohen said of Abbot. “He is allowed to say whatever he wants to say, and he has, but that doesn’t mean that he’s free from consequences.”

And while universities should uphold academic freedoms, Cohen said institutions also have a responsibility to consider the communities that their students and faculties are a part of. 

“It comes down to who is being harmed,” she said. “Universities don’t have a responsibility to platform people who are harming others.”

Still, Whittington said Abbot’s case differs from other cancellations because the views expressed in Abbot’s op-ed were unrelated to the topic of his planned lecture at MIT.

“We’re not talking about some outside provocateur that a student group brought to campus,” Whittington said. “We’re talking about a distinguished scientist who was invited to give a scientific talk and people were saying he can’t do that because he also happens to hold political beliefs they disagree with.”

Whittington and his colleagues at the Academic Freedom Alliance sent a letter Monday to MIT asking that the institution take actions to address and rectify the situation.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Mother luckily escapes injury as baby's cry brings her out of kitchen seconds before explosion

A mother luckily escaped death as her baby's cry brought her out of the kitchen seconds before an explosion in southern China. Video shot in the city of Zhanjiang in ... Read more »

Why Microsoft avoided antitrust scrutiny that plagued other tech giants in 2021

The Big Tech reckoning gained momentum in 2021, as U.S. regulators accused behemoths like Google and Facebook of abusing their market power to gain an illegal edge over competitors. But ... Read more »

10-year-old fidget toy maker set to retire by age 15

10-year-old fidget toy maker set to retire by age 15 A 10-year-old entrepreneur from Australia – who has a toy and hair accessory empire – is set to retire by ... Read more »

Microsoft is Yahoo Finance's Company of the Year 2021

Microsoft (MSFT) has had a stunning year. After nearly 50 years in business, the tech giant crashed through the $2 trillion market capitalization mark in June, joining an exclusive club ... Read more »

Coronation Street's Roy Cropper actor to make a Christmas comeback

David Neilson playing Roy Cropper in Coronation Street credit:Bang Showbiz David Neilson is set to return as Roy Cropper in a dramatic Christmas 'Coronation Street' comeback just weeks after exiting ... Read more »

Amanda Owen makes very candid comment about family 'difficulties' in new interview

Our Yorkshire Farm star Amanda Owen has opened up about facing “difficult moments” in a new interview with Lorraine Kelly. MORE: Amanda Owen's fans jump to her defence after she ... Read more »

Reintroducing masks in England may be met with resistance – here's how the government can overcome it

Richard M Lee/Shutterstock There are fears that the new omicron variant of the coronavirus could be the most transmissible form of the virus yet, so infection control measures are being ... Read more »

Elon Musk says SpaceX is building a launch pad for Starship orbital flights on Florida's eastern coastline

SpaceX‘s Starship and CEO Elon Musk.SpaceX; Britta Pedersen-Pool/Getty Images SpaceX has started building a launch pad in Florida for Starship rocket flights, Elon Musk said. It will have a better ... Read more »

These Are The Last Christmas Posting Dates For 2021

(Photo: Sergio Amiti via Getty Images) The festive lights have been turned on and the mince pies are out in full force, which means one thing: it’s time to send ... Read more »

Euro 2020 and sea shanties among TikTok's highlights of the year

Cats, sea shanties and Euro 2020 were among the biggest trends on TikTok in the UK during 2021, according to figures from the video-sharing platform. The social media giant’s annual ... Read more »

Looking for a holiday gift? The new Nintendo Switch is 'worth the upgrade' — plus more hot tech finds from Best Buy

Looking for more of the best deals, sales and product recommendations? Sign up for Yahoo Lifestyle Canada’s newsletter! Shoppers say the Nintendo Switch OLED Model is “worth the upgrade.” Yahoo ... Read more »

Fauci says early data on the Omicron variant is 'encouraging' but we don't yet truly know how deadly it is

Dr. Anthony Fauci.AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, Pool Dr. Anthony Fauci said Sunday that South Africa's initial data on Omicron is “a bit encouraging.” However, the top US medical doctor said ... Read more »

Elon Musk 'is making the rules' in space with rapid expansion of SpaceX's Starlink internet service, agency boss says

SpaceX CEO Elon Musk.Pool Elon Musk is “making the rules” in space, European Space Agency boss told the Financial Times. The ESA boss urged European countries to stop enabling Musk ... Read more »

Why the UK shouldn't introduce mandatory COVID vaccination

As coronavirus infections surge across Europe, and with the threat of the omicron variant looming, countries are imposing increasingly stringent pandemic controls. In Austria, citizens will be subject to a ... Read more »

Astronomers decode why our Solar System is shaped like a croissant

BU-led scientists say the protective bubble around the solar system is shaped like a croissant (Image courtesy of Opher, et. al) Hydrogen particles slamming into the Solar System from outside ... Read more »

Does vaping really damage DNA and increase the risk of cancer?

Vapers experience DNA changes, according to a recent paper published in Nature, and the changes are similar to those seen in smokers – although much less pronounced. Crucially, this evidence ... Read more »

One in four colds is likely down to COVID, expert warns

Boris Johnson will review current COVID-19 measures on 18 December. (PA Images) One in four colds is likely down to people having coronavirus, an expert has said. Tim Spector, a ... Read more »

Johnson: We need to invest in rehab to help drug users

Boris Johnson says “everybody who knows about drugs crime will tell you” there needs to be more investment in rehab to drive down crime. He argues, however, that the government ... Read more »

I'm a Celebrity: Snoochie Shy opens up about revealing her birthmark for the first time

The radio presenter said she used to cover up her birthmark with make-up but feels more like herself for revealing it. Read more »

Oura ring review: Does the celeb-favourite activity tracker live up the hype?

We considered its tracking ability, how comfortable it was to wear and the app’s features (The Independent) Since hitting the smart tech market a few years ago, Oura’s health tracker ... Read more »

Arthur Labinjo-Hughes: Father and stepmum sat in hot tub while boy left in hallway for hours

The case of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes has shocked the nation. (PA) The killers of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes relaxed in a hot tub while the six-year-old boy was left alone for hours, it ... Read more »

Astrophotographer snaps his 'clearest ever photo of the SUN', revealing swirls and feather-type patterns on the solar surface

Photographer Andrew McCarthy layered 150,000 individual pictures of the sun to create the imageThe resulting photo is an enormous 300 megapixels - 30 times bigger than a standard imageIn its most close-up view, swirls and feather-type patterns can be seen alongside black hole formations Read more »

Man, 38, finds tooth in his NOSE in rare case of an 'ectopic tooth' that was affecting his ability to breathe

A 38-year-old man was discovered to have a tooth in his nose by doctors at New York City's Mount Sinai hospital The man went for treatment after years of having trouble breathing out of his right nostrilAn initial examination discovered that he had a deviated septum, and a rhinoscopy found the protruding toothSurgery was performed to remove the tooth, and three months later the man told doctors his breathing problems had gone awayEntopic teeth are rare, appearing in less than 1% of the population, though health officials warn that patients should get them treated when discovered  Read more »

Little change in gender pay gap over past 25 years, study finds

Office workers The gender pay gap has seen “barely any change” over the past 25 years once increases in women's education are accounted for, a report has said. The Institute ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy tab S7 FE review: Can this affordable tablet rival Apple's iPad?

We tested for ease of set up, speed and responsiveness in everyday use (iStock/The Independent) When choosing a tablet, you’ll have to make a few decisions. What size screen are ... Read more »

F1 news LIVE: Max Verstappen penalised as Lewis Hamilton accuses rival of going too far in Saudi Arabia

Follow all the latest F1 news and reaction after Lewis Hamilton won a chaotic Saudi Arabian Grand Prix to draw level with Max Verstappen in the standings with only one ... Read more »

Users face removal of passports and driving licences under Boris Johnson's new 10-year drugs plan

Harsher punishments to deter drug use, including the removal of passports and driving licences, night-time curfews and travel bans like those imposed on football hooligans, will form part of a ... Read more »

British teenager attacked by 10ft crocodile describes relief at not losing leg

Amele Osborn-Smith, 18, from Andover, Hampshire, spoke from hospital in Zambia, where she’s recovering from a crocodile bite while white-water rafting near Victoria Falls. Read more »

PS5 UK stock - live: PlayStation Direct restock is set to drop this morning – how to get a console

PS5 UK stock – live: PlayStation Direct restock is set to drop this morning – how to get a console UPDATE: The PS5 is set to drop at PlayStation Direct ... Read more »

Xbox series X UK stock - live: Who could restock Microsoft's console today?

We’re expecting more restocks at major UK retailers soon (The Independent) The Xbox series X is Microsoft’s fastest-selling console, but despite its apparent success the next-generation games machine is still ... Read more »

On This Day: When will we know if there's life on Mars?

Gullies on the wall of the Terra Sirenum crater (Photo by NASA/JPL/MSSS/Getty Images) This article is part of Yahoo's 'On This Day' series. When astronomer Percival Lowell spotted what he ... Read more »

Starwatch: Jupiter, Saturn and Venus chart the moon's movement

Jupiter and Saturn will showcase the moon’s phases with Venus providing additional markers along the way starwatch 6/12/21 This week we can again take advantage of Jupiter and Saturn’s placement ... Read more »

Two hippos at Belgian zoo test positive for Covid in first for species

Hippos Imani, 14 and Hermien, 41 at the Antwerp Zoo in Belgium have tested positive for Covid-19 (Antwerp Zoo/Jonas Verhulst) Two hippos at the Antwerp zoo in Belgium have tested ... Read more »

Taking some of the guesswork out of drug discovery

A deep learning model rapidly predicts the 3D shapes of drug-like molecules, which could accelerate the process of discovering new medicines. Read more »

China ‘modified' the weather to create clear skies for political celebration – study

Researchers say Beijing used cloud-seeding to create artificial rain and lower pollution in July, in latest example of ‘blueskying’ efforts Chinese weather authorities successfully controlled the weather ahead of a ... Read more »

3D-printed suicide capsules are now legal in Switzerland

Dutch designer Alexander Bannink explains how the “Sarco” euthanasia pod works as a woman experiences sitting in the device by wearing virtual reality glasses, on April 14, 2018 at the ... Read more »

Seahawks hold on late for wild 30-23 win over 49ers

1/1049ers Seahawks FootballSeattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson looks to pass against the San Francisco 49ers during the second half of an NFL football game, Sunday, Dec. 5, 2021, in Seattle. ... Read more »

Study shows men spread COVID particles more than women and children

Fort Collins, Colorado – A study focused on tracking the spread of COVID-19 in performing arts settings has also unveiled the population of humans who spread the most COVID-19 particles. ... Read more »

Liquid hydrogen aircraft plan for zero carbon transatlantic flights

A liquid hydrogen-powered plane is being developed in an attempt to operate non-stop zero carbon transatlantic flights. The midsize aircraft is being designed to carry 279 passengers at the same ... Read more »

Lil Nas X Embodies His Own Positive Light in This White Bandage Top and Suit

Lil Nas X was presented with the 2021 Innovator of the Year award at the Variety Hitmakers event by his good friend Chloe Bailey. When she took the stage to ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic