Abortion bans could make maternal mortality so much worse in the US

Amanda Jean Stevenson is an assistant professor of Sociology at University of Colorado Boulder. This story originally featured on The Conversation.

© Nylos/Unsplash Abortion bans like the one in Texas could exacerbate the already-high mortality rates for pregnant people in the US.

A new Texas law bans nearly all abortions, and other states have indicated that they likely will follow suit. But the research is clear that people who want abortions but are unable to get them can suffer a slew of negative consequences for their health and well-being.

As a researcher who measures the effects of contraception and abortion policy on people’s lives, I usually have to wait years for the data to roll in. But sometimes anticipating a policy’s effects before they happen can suggest ways to avoid its worst consequences.

In my forthcoming peer-reviewed paper, currently available as a preprint, I found that if the US ends all abortions nationwide, pregnancy-related deaths will increase substantially because carrying a pregnancy to term can be deadlier than having an abortion.

Banning abortion does not stop people from trying to end their pregnancies. But it won’t result in a return to the kinds of unsafe abortion that killed hundreds of women per year before the Supreme Court’s ruling Roe v. Wade legalized abortion in the US.

Recent advances in medication abortion, which relies on prescription drugs rather than a procedure, have made safer abortions outside of clinics possible. They set the stage for organizations like Plan C to help pregnant people safely manage their own abortions with pills if they want or need to.

Staying pregnant, on the other hand, carries a greater risk of death for the pregnant person than having an abortion. Abortion is incredibly safe for pregnant people in the US, with 0.44 deaths per 100,000 procedures from 2013 to 2017. In contrast, 20.1 deaths per 100,000 live births occurred in 2019. In the US, pregnancy-related deaths occur for many reasons, including cardiovascular conditions, infections and hemorrhage caused or worsened by being pregnant or giving birth.


Policies like the abortion bans sweeping the US may affect pregnancy-related deaths in several ways. In my study, I estimated a portion of the additional deaths that would be caused by a nationwide ban on all abortions.

To do this, I used published US pregnancy and abortion death rates to project how many deaths would occur if all pregnancies that currently end in abortion were instead continued to miscarriage or term. My conservative estimate found that the annual number of pregnancy-related deaths would increase by 21 percent overall, or 140 additional deaths, by the second year after a ban.

Among non-Hispanic Black woman, this percentage would increase 33 percent, causing 78 additional deaths and exacerbating the ongoing US Black maternal health crisis. The pregnancy-related death rate for non-Hispanic Black women is about three times higher than for non-Hispanic white women and Hispanic or Latino women, likely because of structural racism, biases in health care provision and disparities in health care access, among other reasons.

In reality, these figures could be higher. They do not account for the fact that people having abortions are on average less advantaged than people having births and at a higher risk of pregnancy-related death. Nor do they include the risks of using less safe abortion methods.

Projections always rely on assumptions about how the future will unfold—they are warnings, not predictions. My estimates describe how deaths would increase if everyone who currently has abortions instead carries their pregnancy to term.

But the federal government, other states, and nongovernmental organizations could make state abortion bans less deadly.

The assumptions behind my projections show us how to prevent what I warn could happen. For example, effectively addressing the maternal health crisis could make pregnancy safer and reduce pregnancy-related deaths. Helping people access safe medication abortion and travel across state lines to get to an abortion clinic would reduce pregnancy-related deaths. And not banning abortion in the first place would reduce pregnancy-related deaths the most.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


WOMADelaide announces mandatory COVID-19 vaccination as 2022 festival returns to Botanic Park

World music festival WOMADelaide has announced patrons must be fully vaccinated to attend in 2022. WOMADelaide director Ian Scobie told ABC Radio Adelaide’s Ali Clarke this morning that the rule would ... Read more »

Lin-Manuel Miranda and Daveed Diggs arrive at Freestyle Love Supreme

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Lin-Manuel Miranda was joined by his Hamilton collaborator Daveed Diggs on the red carpet of the Freestyle Love Supreme premiere. The 41-year-old actor-writer-director ... Read more »

Melissa and Bryce give an update on their twins

© Provided by Are Media Pty Ltd Bryce Ruthven and Melissa Rawson have given their fans an update on their twins after the newborns arrived 10 weeks early. The couple ... Read more »

Explainer: What Phase B of the national COVID-19 plan means

Australia has officially passed the critical milestone of 70 per cent of the 16+ population fully vaccinated, triggering “Phase B” of the national plan out of the COVID-19 pandemic. The ... Read more »

Threat from foreign spies to surpass terrorism, ASIO warns

Australia’s domestic intelligence agency is warning foreign spies are behind “sophisticated and wide-ranging” attempts to interfere with the country’s affairs. Agents from multiple rival powers are harnessing technology in their ... Read more »

Qld govt to invest $7.1b in 65 trains

The Queensland government has called for tenders for a $7.1 billion contract to build 65 trains in the formerly thriving regional railway town of Maryborough. © Jono Searle/AAP PHOTOS Annastacia ... Read more »

Two dead in Sydney underworld shooting

The feud between two warring underworld families has been reignited after a daylight drive-by shooting left two men dead in Sydney’s southwest. © Dan Himbrechts/AAP PHOTOS Police have set up ... Read more »

Canberra primary school principal criticises ACT government COVID-19 vaccine mandate in Facebook video alongside One Nation senator

© Provided by ABC NEWS Charnwood-Dunlop School Principal Rob Lans has criticised the ACT government’s vaccine mandates for primary school teachers and early childhood educators.  (ABC Canberra: Adrienne Francis) A Canberra ... Read more »

Lexus to take on Carnival and Staria?

Lexus could be gearing up for a tilt at Australia’s people-mover segment, with a trademark surfacing for the brand’s LM model, which would give families a luxurious alternative to vehicles ... Read more »

Perrottet's act of faith as Catholic Church circles on voluntary assisted dying laws

Well that didn’t take long.  © Provided by Crikey Dominic Perrottet NSW Voluntary assisted dying legislation was billed as the first test for New South Wales Premier Dominic Perrott and ... Read more »

Parents slam 'selfish' bride for excluding autistic sister from wedding

It can be hard to deal with family members with special needs, especially at important events like weddings where they may be unable to behave “appropriately”. One woman has had ... Read more »

NSW men charged over alleged COVID fraud

Two NSW men have been charged as investigations continue into alleged fraudulent COVID-19 grants and drug supply offences on the Central Coast. Detectives yesterday raided a home in Mardi, 70 ... Read more »

Afghan interpreter who worked with Australian troops murdered by Taliban

When Afghanistan fell to the Taliban there were dire warnings that Afghans who had worked with coalition troops would be targeted by the Taliban. This week, a former Afghan soldier ... Read more »

Qld could scrap quarantine for green zones

Queensland will look at scrapping quarantine for international travellers entering the state from green zones after it reopened to flights from New Zealand’s South Island. © Jono Searle/AAP PHOTOS Dr ... Read more »

13 Types Of Online Daters Who Have Emerged During The Pandemic

(Photo: Dusan Stankovic via Getty Images) Dating app usage spiked last year, meaning the dating pool grew exponentially for singles looking for love (or something like it.) Yes, that means ... Read more »

Frank Sinatra's My Way loses top spot in funeral music request chart

Gerry and the Pacemakers’ emotional melody You’ll Never Walk Alone has hit the top spot in Co-op Funeralcare’s annual music chart of the most popular songs at funerals. The song ... Read more »

BenQ Mobiuz EX3415R review

Two-minute review While pro gamers are going to use flat, small 16:9 screens because they’re the fastest, most colour accurate and consistent screens around – for anyone that actually wants ... Read more »

Will you be wearing the bizarre trend set to take off this summer?

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A bizarre fashion trend is set to dominate offices across Australia as workers dress to the nines after months of lounging in lockdown ... Read more »

Big Brother VIP: Channel Seven announces premiere date for new season

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Big Brother VIP will premiere on Monday, November 1. Channel Seven confirmed the launch date for the highly anticipated reality TV show on ... Read more »

Abetz denies Ernies award remarks

Tasmanian Senator Eric Abetz has challenged the outcome of the 29th Annual Ernies Awards for Sexism, vehemently denying he ever made the comments that netted him the top gong.  © ... Read more »

Brisbane's Australian Country Choice meatworks suspended from exports to China

A ninth Australian meatworks has been suspended from trading meat to China. Brisbane-based Australian Country Choice (ACC) was alerted by Australian authorities this morning that its trade to China has ... Read more »

The telling clue that Emma Watkins was going to quit The Wiggles months before announcement

Fans are convinced Emma Watkins made the decision to leave The Wiggles months before her announcement. The Yellow Wiggle, 32, revealed on Tuesday that she would be departing the children’s ... Read more »

Ava Hewitt is the spitting image of her mother Bec on 11th birthday

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo She’s the youngest daughter of Lleyton and Bec Hewitt.  And Ava Hewitt looked to be the spitting image of her famous mother in a ... Read more »

Tasmania reaches 70 per cent double-dose COVID vaccination rate

Premier Peter Gutwein says 70 per cent of Tasmanians aged over 16 are fully vaccinated against COVID-19 as of today. It marks a milestone on the same day Federal Health ... Read more »

NSW train derailment a crime scene

A man was seen running from the tracks just before a fast-moving early morning passenger train slammed into a stolen van that had been abandoned on the tracks at a ... Read more »

Health minister reveals child death threat

Federal Health Minister Greg Hunt has revealed death threats against his children as he condemned anti-vaccine protesters pursuing the NT chief minister. © Lukas Coch/AAP PHOTOS Health Minister Greg Hunt ... Read more »

Trump wanted to send half the Army to the border during the pandemic

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Donald Trump wanted to bring in 250,000 troops to the border wall to help secure the U.S. southern border with Mexico during the ... Read more »

Brooke Blurton reveals who was her best first kiss

© Provided by Are Media Pty Ltd The Bachelorette Brooke Blurton revealed to Fitzy & Wippa some saucy details about her winner and their more successful attempt at this go-to ... Read more »

Weary mums share the 'easy' 10-minute family dinners they make

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Weary mums have revealed the 10-minute family dinners they serve up when they are too exhausted to prepare a full meal. The dishes ... Read more »

Queen Elizabeth says world leaders have a 'shared responsibility' to tackle the 'challenges of climate change'

Queen Elizabeth has called on business leaders and governments to work together “to avert the challenges of climate change”. Her Majesty said those in power had a “shared responsibility to ... Read more »

Father and son gunned down as Sydney gangland war escalates

© Provided by ABC NEWS A crime scene was established after NSW Police were called to Osgood Street in Guildford. (ABC News) A daylight shooting in Sydney that left a ... Read more »

Every adult in NSW to receive $50 travel voucher

All adults in NSW will receive a $50 “Stay and Rediscover” voucher to use towards accommodation to boost the state’s tourism sector. NSW Premier Dominic Perrottet announced more than $500 ... Read more »

House Capitol attack committee votes to recommend Steve Bannon prosecution

The House select committee investigating the Capitol attack voted on Tuesday to recommend the criminal prosecution of Donald Trump’s former chief strategist Steve Bannon, after he defied a subpoena relating ... Read more »

Net zero attracts net stupidity and net self-righteousness

We are seeing history repeat itself in the government. The same small group of climate deniers who killed off the National Energy Guarantee in Turnbull’s years are now holding Australia ... Read more »

Celebrity cook Donna Hay reveals her 'secret flavour weapons'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Australia’s iconic cookbook author Donna Hay has shared her ‘secret flavour weapons’ and the go-to ingredient for taking simple dishes to the next ... Read more »

NRL star faces court on assault charges

NRL star and former Broncos playmaker Anthony Milford has faced court for the first time following assault charges after an alleged disturbance in Brisbane’s nightlife precinct. © Darren England/AAP PHOTOS ... Read more »

Vaccine landmark hit as booster shots near

Australia has reached a significant milestone, with 70 per cent of people aged 16 fully vaccinated protected as a booster rollout draws closer. © Lukas Coch/AAP PHOTOS Health Minister Greg ... Read more »

This hidden condition has left half of sufferers feeling 'unsupported' through pandemic

Model Lila Grace Moss Hack walks the runway at the Versace special event with her Type 1 diabetes insulin pump visible. (Getty Images ) Half of people living with type ... Read more »

The hottest new crypto trend: What is the Tungsten Cube?

Cubes of tungsten carbide. Photo: Thierry Zoccolan/AFP via Getty Images Over the last week crypto watchers have been abuzz about the new hottest commodity: the Tungsten Cube. No, it’s not ... Read more »

Big Brother VIP's premiere date is revealed

© Provided by Are Media Pty Ltd After months of rumours and excitement, Channel Seven has finally revealed the premiere date for its highly-anticipated Big Brother VIP. Twelve VIPs will ... Read more »