A trio of conservative radio hosts died of Covid. Will their deaths change vaccine resistance?

"There's no question ... when you read he [Phil Valentine] has it and then three weeks later he's dead, it will get your attention," a conservative host said.

First it was Dick Farrel. Then Phil Valentine. Most recently, Marc Bernier. Just within the past month, those three conservative radio hosts — all unvaccinated critics of inoculation efforts — died after contracting Covid.

Will their deaths help sway any minds of unvaccinated listeners or the broader segment of conservatives resistant to the shots? Some fellow personalities think so — although the optimism is limited.

“There’s no question when somebody like Phil Valentine, when you read that he has it and then three weeks later he’s dead, it will get your attention,” said John Fredericks, a pro-Trump conservative radio personality who said he is vaccinated.

Nearly nine months into the inoculation campaign, the political divide over Covid vaccinations is still gaping. But conservative media counterparts see a chance to soften some resistance on the right after trusted messengers who have mocked the shots or otherwise encouraged audiences to resist efforts to get them vaccinated have died.

Study shows Covid vaccines remain effective against severe illness and hospitalizations

Sept. 2, 202103:39

It is an indication of just how influential local conservative radio hosts, many of them hardly known outside their local or regional communities, continue to be for many Republicans.

“I think, certainly in the case of Phil Valentine and Farrel, who both had recanted their anti-Covid vaccine views before their deaths, it could have as much impact as anybody could possibly have,” said Jim Bohannon, a longtime right-of-center radio host. “For Marc Bernier, who maintained his stance as Mr. Anti-Vax till his death and never publicly recanted a thing, I think the impact will be less, although certainly it must be hard for people” to see his death and not question their stances on vaccination.

With the delta variant of the coronavirus having surged across much of the South as states like Florida experience record case, hospitalization and death counts, the overwhelming majority of Covid hospitalizations and deaths nationwide are among unvaccinated people, NBC News reported last month.

Bernier, 65, a longtime conservative radio personality in Daytona Beach, Florida, died last week, as announced by WNDB, the radio station he broadcast from. A little more than three weeks before, Farrel, 65, who formerly hosted shows for several Florida stations and was a fill-in anchor on Newsmax, succumbed to the virus. Between their deaths was Valentine’s. The 61-year-old hosted a prominent Nashville-based radio program.

Marc Bernier during a radio interview Oct. 24, 2006, in Washington, D.C.Mandel Ngan / AFP via Getty Images file

Each had publicly either mocked vaccination or derided broader vaccination efforts. Bernier, who called himself “Mr. Anti-Vax,” said on Twitter that the Biden administration’s push for vaccine intake was Nazi-esque. Farrel posted to Facebook in July: “why take a vax promoted by people who lied 2u all along about masks, where the virus came from and the death toll?” And Valentine questioned why he should get the shots and risk side effects when he was at low risk of death. Before they died, Farrel and Valentine changed their postures.

Politics have played a key role in who is and is not getting the shots, as NBC News polling has shown. A recent survey found that just 55 percent of Republicans have been vaccinated, which drops to 50 percent among Trump voters and 46 percent among Republicans who support former President Donald Trump more than the party — each total among the lowest of any demographic group surveyed. In contrast, 91 percent of Biden voters said they have gotten vaccinated. In addition, a Kaiser Family Foundation vaccination tracking poll released last month found that Republicans were the second-least-likely demographic group to be vaccinated.

That can be a signal for conservative media personalities to play into their audiences’ skepticism.

“A lot of people, of course, are going to do what they think will improve their ratings and will appeal to their core audience,” said Bohannon, who got vaccinated as soon as a vaccine was available to him. “I know these people are whores in the worst sense of the term. … Others, I think, may be more open and may, in fact, go ahead and alter their view.”

Southern Stone Communications and Cumulus Media, the companies that own the radio stations Bernier and Valentine broadcast from, did not respond to requests for comment about the hosts’ deaths.

Matthew Sheffield, a former conservative media creator who has left the movement and is now at the media platform Flux, said that he hopes some listeners will learn from what happened but that as for any change in messaging, “that’s just not how things work there in that media world.”

“There’s too much money to be had. And blind people,” Sheffield said. “So it’s not going to change. The only thing that people in right-wing media are going to respond to are legal threats. The death of their colleagues means nothing, but the loss of their personal fortunes is meaningful to them. And that says a lot.”

But even when it is delivered by icons of the far right, a pro-vaccination message can fall upon deaf ears. Late last month, Trump was greeted by some boos at an Alabama rally after he told supporters they should get vaccinated.

Don Thrasher, former chair of Nelson County, Kentucky, GOP, is one such Republican for whom Trump’s message falls flat. He said in an email that the recent deaths of conservative radio hosts “would give some people pause to reconsider, but there are a lot of people including myself that are still hesitant.”

He said that hesitancy extends outside the conservative world and that “the sooner we have open and honest debate on these groups’ concerns and not the demeaning, condescending attitude of ‘do as we say,’ the better.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Scottish Dunes Trump Promised To Protect On His Golf Course Are Ruined

Environmentally critical coastal sand dunes on Donald Trump’s Scottish golf course in Aberdeenshire have been ruined, even though Trump promised to protect them. The dunes “will be there forever,” Trump ... Read more »

US throws out millions of doses of Covid vaccine as world goes wanting

Photograph: Nathan Posner/Rex/Shutterstock The United States is wasting millions of Covid-19 vaccine doses even as shortages plague many parts of the world. At least 15m doses were scrapped in the ... Read more »

'My first Chromebook and I'm never going back': This popular Chromebook laptop comes with a drawing tablet — and it's $90 off!

We may receive commission from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability are subject to change. Save 26 percent on the Acer Chromebook Spin 311. (Photo: Amazon/Getty) ... Read more »

5 things about the Google Pixel 6 we have left to learn

The Google Pixel 6 is almost here, and a combination of rumors and official disclosures has given us plenty to suspect and expect, respectively, about the new handset. But there’s ... Read more »

Mick Jagger Hits Back at Paul McCartney In Concert: 'He's Going to Join Us in a Blues Cover Later'

Mick Jagger Will Lester/getty The longstanding rivalry between the Beatles and the Stones has a new chapter. At the Rolling Stones concert at the SoFi Stadium in Los Angeles on ... Read more »

Is flexible working making us work more?

While remote working can be beneficial, some have reported how it is difficult to switch off from their duties, especially if computers, papers and other office ephemera are on view. ... Read more »

Lourdes Leon Says Her Mom, Madonna, Was a "Control Freak"

Photo credit: Instagram Lourdes Leon is getting real about her relationship with legendary mother, Madonna. In a new conversation with Interview, Leon opened up about her experience growing up as ... Read more »

Singer Olly Murs eyeing up 2022 'Strictly Come Dancing' slot

Olly Murs is a ‘Strictly’ fan. (Ian West/PA Images via Getty Images) Olly Murs has offered himself up as a future Strictly Come Dancing contestant, joking that his old boss ... Read more »

Scarce chips may pinch Apple's iPhone holiday sales

The global chip shortage could be creeping its way to Apple‘s newest iPhone 13 smartphones, but analysts think that the technology giant can weather the impact by making up for ... Read more »

Redmi Note 11 Pro 5G price, Redmi Note 11 5G specifications leaked

Redmi Note 11 and Note 11 Pro 5G specifications have leaked online. Xiaomi is expected to launch the Redmi Note 11 series next year in China. These devices could arrive ... Read more »

Dbrand pulls its PS5 Darkplates from sale after Sony threatens legal action

Earlier this year, Dbrand started selling matte black PS5 side plates that it called Darkplates, and when it did, it baited Sony right on the product’s info page to “Go ... Read more »

Detective's apology over ‘terrible' mistakes in Stephen Port probe

A senior detective investigating serial killer Stephen Port has apologised to the families of his victims, after admitting a series of “terrible” personal errors on the case. Detective Sergeant Martin ... Read more »

Heather Locklear Refused to Wear Fake Butt Padding on T.J. Hooker : 'It Was Really Padded'

t getty Heather Locklear had to put her foot down on the set of one of her most beloved series. The six-time Golden Globe nominee, 60, recalled an incident on ... Read more »

Making a Movie Is Hard. Making One in Space Is Insane.

Audrey Shelepin/GCTC/Roscosmos/Handout via Reuters On October 5, a Russian Soyuz spacecraft flew into space with three people onboard, and docked with the International Space Station a few hours later. The ... Read more »

Apple sacks the leader of the #AppleToo movement for "deleting these apps"

NEW DELHI: Apple has reportedly fired Janneke Parrish, a leader of the #AppleToo movement. According to a report in The Verge, Parrish, a program manager on Apple Maps, was terminated ... Read more »

Wild Rift's 2.5 patch adds three new champions, guilds, and more

(Photos: Riot Games) The 2.5 patch for League of Legends: Wild Rift comes almost a year after the game's release and the Wild Rift team have made sure that the ... Read more »

The unexpected benefits of playing video games at work

One of the few silver linings of the pandemic is that it has thrown into stark relief the problems with working culture that have gone unaddressed for decades. Ironically, despite ... Read more »

IPL 2022: 3 Teams Who Can Target Hardik Pandya In Mega Auction

Hardik Pandya-Mumbai Indians Predicted Playing XI IPL 2022 will be a 10-team affair with two new teams coming into the fold. Ahmedabad and Lucknow are the cities likely to be ... Read more »

The Australian sprinter whose career was killed by the 'Black Power' podium protest

US athletes Tommie Smith, centre, and John Carlos, right, raise their fists in protest on the podium in Mexivo City in 1968, behind Australian sprinter Peter Norman, left. (Getty) This ... Read more »

CATL's EV battery breakthrough holds promise as cost-effective, game-changing alternative the industry's waiting for

The first of a three-part series on battery packs looks at the world’s largest producer CATL and how it occupies the apex of a technological revolution to assemble cheaper and ... Read more »

1,151 adolescents aged 15-17 years old got COVID-19 vaccine on 1st day —NTF

© DR. JONAS DEL ROSARIO/PGH A young girl is among the first to get inoculated against COVID-19 during the start of the vaccination for adolescents aged 12 to 17 years ... Read more »

Everything we know about Google's Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro so far

Google‘s Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro will officially be launched on October 19, and in typical fashion, we know a ton of details about the phones well before their ... Read more »

Apple reportedly just fired another employee who brought attention to issues at the company

Apple CEO Tim Cook. Yves Herman/Reuters Apple just fired a staffer who helped organize employees at the company, The Verge reported. Janneke Parrish was an Apple Maps program manager who ... Read more »

Devils, Blackhawks honour late Jimmy Hayes in warm-ups

Ahead of the New Jersey Devils’ season opener against the Chicago Blackhawks on Friday, both teams paid tribute to Jimmy Hayes, a former player they lost earlier this summer. The ... Read more »

State-sponsored attackers infiltrate Play Store with fake VPN app

Spyware can come in many forms and in May of last year, Google’s Threat Analysis Group discovered that state-sponsored hackers had disguised their malicious software as a VPN app and ... Read more »

China lags in important electric car technology despite rare earths advantage, says permanent magnets scientist

Chinese electric carmakers are still lagging behind their foreign rivals in permanent magnet (PM) motor innovation despite the fact that China is the world’s dominant supplier of the rare earth ... Read more »

What the COVID-19 vaccine booster data still can't tell us

This past week, a panel of independent FDA advisors has voted to recommend booster shots of both the Moderna and Johnson & Johnson COVID vaccines.  © Knartz/Deposit Photos An FDA ... Read more »

A Mysterious 'Ghost Particle' Probably Didn't Come From a Black Hole's Meal After All

© DESY, Science Communication Lab Animation of AT2019dsg. A high-energy neutrino traced back to a violent encounter between a black hole and a star needs a different origin story, new ... Read more »

[INTERVIEW] ASM provides diversity in critical metals supply chain

ASM’s rare earth mine site in Dubbo, New South Wales, Australia / Courtesy of ASM Strategic partnership with ASM creates stable, direct supply chain for rare earth metals By Anna ... Read more »

Justice Department to Ask Supreme Court to Strike Down Texas Abortion Law

The Justice Department will petition the Supreme Court to strike down Texas’s law prohibiting abortion after a fetal heartbeat can be detected, a spokesperson announced Friday. It was not immediately ... Read more »

Aviation, tourism industries rushing to prepare for 'living with COVID-19'

Traveler wait to check in at Terminal 2 of Incheon International Airport, Oct. 4. Yonhap By Jun Ji-hyeExpectations toward demand recovery for overseas travel are rising in the aviation and ... Read more »

Microsoft is toying with a new way to roll out Windows 11 updates

Following the launch of Windows 11, Microsoft has revealed that it is currently in the process of testing out a new way to deliver updates to the latest version of ... Read more »

After seeing new leaked photos of the Pixel 6, I think I finally get the phone's unusual design

We’re just a few days away from Google’s October 19th launch event for the Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro, but if you want an early look at what to ... Read more »

Acer Predator Triton 500 SE

The Acer Predator Triton 500 SE is Acer’s flagship gaming laptop, featuring intel Core i7 processor, an Nvidia GeForce RTX 3060 GPU, 16 GB RAM and a 512 GB SSD. ... Read more »

Claudio Ranieri wants to get best out of Ismaila Sarr versus Liverpool

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Claudio Ranieri admits he must devise a tactical plan to maximise the talent of Ismaila Sarr as he prepares to face Liverpool in ... Read more »

A year later, Apple's MagSafe continues to underwhelm

One year ago yesterday, I wrote how MagSafe could be the biggest reason to buy an iPhone 12. I believed it, too. It looked like Apple had cracked the code ... Read more »

How To Watch NASA's Lucy Launch—A Cosmic Hunt for Asteroids

At 5:34 a.m. E.T. on Saturday, NASA’s Lucy mission is scheduled to launch from the Florida Space Coast region. The mission is designed to study Jupiter’s Trojan asteroids—named for famous ... Read more »

Thomas Tuchel backs Anthony Taylor. puts Reece James red card in past

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Thomas Tuchel insists he has faith in Anthony Taylor as the referee takes charge of Chelsea just seven weeks after sparking an angry ... Read more »

US Treasury says ransomware payouts in 2021 could top entire past decade

© Illustration by Alex Castro / The Verge The ransomware business is booming this year and could be bringing in billions for some of its top players, according to a ... Read more »

The best early Black Friday deal is LG's C1 OLED TV on sale for a record-low price

Looking for early Black Friday deals? We spotted LG’s stunning C1 OLED TV down to a record-low price last week, and surprisingly it’s still around. Amazon has the 65-inch C1 ... Read more »