A Tennessee judge created and used policies - and a non-existent law - to jail children, investigation finds

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Provided by INSIDER Judge Donna Scott Davenport is accused of creating policies that led to children being illegally arrested and detained. rutherfordcountytn.gov

  • A juvenile court judge implemented policies that permitted jailing and detaining children, many of them Black, without sufficient cause, according to an investigation.
  • The Tennessee county settled a class-action lawsuit for $11 million after lawyers alleged the policy departed from Tennessee law.
  • The policy has been halted and Davenport maintains her position as the Rutherford County Juvenile Court Judge.

A Tennessee juvenile court judge orchestrated a system to arrest and jail children, many of whom were Black and some who were as young as eight and nine years old, according to an investigation by ProPublica and Nashville Public Radio.

According to the report, published on October 8, Juvenile Court Judge Donna Scott Davenport of Rutherford County created a “process” that involved arresting children, taking them into custody at a detention center, and then filing charges against them.

This differed from the norm in Tennessee, where police would typically serve court summonses to children and their parents instead of arresting children and taking them into custody, the investigation found.

Davenport declined an interview with ProPublica and did not immediately respond to Insider’s request for comment. Representatives from Rutherford County and from the state judicial system also did not respond to Insider’s requests for comment.

Under Davenport’s system, in 2016, 11 Black children were arrested and 10 were charged with “criminal responsibility for conduct of another” after they allegedly failed to stop a fight that was captured on video. But the attorney who represented some of the children said “criminal responsibility for conduct of another” is not a charge under Tennessee law.

Rather, it’s a prosecutorial theory, the attorney Frank Ross Brazil told ABC News.

“So, that being applied as a charge in and of itself is unlawful,” said Brazil, who did not immediately respond to Insider’s request for comment Sunday.

Davenport cultivated a public profile as a disciplinarian, discussing her work in interviews and on her monthly segment on WGNS radio. She even referred to herself as the “mother of the county,” the joint investigation found.

“I know I’m harsh, I’m very harsh. I like to think I’m fair, but I’m tough,” Davenport said in a 2015 profile in the Daily News Journal. “Juvenile Court is all about urgency – we are not dealing with the offense, we are dealing with the offender. We work on rehabilitation.”

Davenport’s “process” was challenged in a class-action lawsuit that involved over 1,000 children that alleged Rutherford County violated children’s rights by arresting and detaining them without sufficient cause. A judge involved in the case said that “children in Rutherford County are suffering irreparable harm every day” from a policy that “departs drastically” from the norm, Nashville Public Radio reported.

The case was settled in June of this year, and the ruling permanently halted the juvenile court’s use of Davenport’s policies. Rutherford County agreed to pay up to $11 million, including $7.75 million to the children who were arrested and detained, according to the investigation.

Just around 200 of the 1,500 children included in the class action lawsuit have filed a claim to get the settlement money, News 4 Nashville reported last week.

Following ProPublica and Nashville Public Radio’s investigation, Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee said that “the appropriate judicial authorities should issue a full review” of Judge Davenport.

As of October 12, Davenport is no longer teaching at Middle Tennessee State University, where she was an alumna and adjunct professor, Nashville Public Radio reported.

According to the outlet, the president of the university said that Davenport, “whose actions overseeing Rutherford County Juvenile Court have recently drawn attention in national media reports, is no longer affiliated with the University.”

Read the original article on Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


It's long past time for MTA brass to put an end to costly overtime abuse

The MTA’s overtime reforms haven’t included getting rid of its antiquated system. Christopher Sadowski MTA Inspector General Carolyn Pokorny is sounding the alarm on the transit agency’s $31 million effort ... Read more »

I'm Celebrity disaster only redeemed by the Naughty bits

FRANKIE didn’t go to Hollywood then. She went up the A55, turned left on to the North Wales Expressway for Gwrych Castle and sat there, freezing her whatsits off, until ... Read more »

I'm an OnlyFans star – Men are cool with my job until we start dating, then they always ask the same thing

ONLYFANS star Lana Wolf has revealed she finds it difficult to date due to her saucy antics. The X-rated model, from Glasgow, is arguably Scotland’s most famous adult entertainer and has an ... Read more »

Football airtime celebrating the insufferable

Had to replay it twice to believe I heard it. How could someone — anywhere in public, let alone on national TV — say such a thing? Monday, during Seattle-Washington, ... Read more »

Duchess of Argyll was first-ever victim of revenge porn, says A Very British Scandal star Claire Foy

LONG before influencers and reality TV, Margaret, Duchess of Argyll was famous simply for being famous – until a bombshell divorce revealed nude photos, drugs and a scandalous 88 affairs. ... Read more »

Alcohol content in Christmas puddings slashed by third as makers try to save on costs

CHRISTMAS puddings are getting up to a third less boozy as makers, er, dessert Yuletide spirits. Cognac and brandy are among tipples being reduced to save on costs. Experts explained ... Read more »

Santa impersonators offered £800 a DAY amid Britain's devastating labour shortage

FATHER Christmas impersonators are being offered £800 a shift to spread festive cheer as Britain has hit with a Santa shortage. Hundreds of Father Christmases are needed in grottoes to ... Read more »

Vaccination mandate extended to NYC religious, private school staffers

Mayor Bill de Blasio announced Thursday that staffers at private and religious education schools must provide proof of a first vaccination dose by December 20. Erik Pendzich/Shutterstock Mayor Bill de ... Read more »

America is behind in the new space race China is determined to win

An artist’s rendering of China‘s space station at the World Robot Conference in Beijing in September 2021. AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein In the 1960s, the United States and the Soviet Union ... Read more »

Alan Cumming recalls nude scene with Jessica Lange: ‘You have fantastic boobs'

Alan Cumming’s new memoir “Baggage” is full of juicy tales of life in Hollywood, including one about Jessica Lange. Getty Images Alan Cumming’s breast friend is Jessica Lange. The actor’s ... Read more »

Keith Urban was judgmental about Nicole Kidman's ‘Lucy' voice

NY loves Lucy. Nicole Kidman, the star of the upcoming Lucille Ball biopic “Being the Ricardos,” in theaters Dec. 10 and on Amazon Prime Video Dec. 21, and her co-stars ... Read more »

Jay Williams calls out ESPN for taking Brian Kelly quote out of context

Jay Williams is not happy with the ESPN social media team. Screenshot via Barrett Sports Media Williams, 40, is a host on ESPN Radio’s national morning show alongside Keyshawn Johnson ... Read more »

New Jersey GOP lawmakers defy vaccine mandate

The Associated PressNew Jersey Assembly member Brian Bergen, left, stands with fellow GOP Assembly member Erik Peterson, right, who speaks and gestures toward New Jersey State troopers blocking GOP lawmakers ... Read more »

The Thing Spider-Man Producers Demanded Kirsten Dunst Change About Her Looks

Matt Winkelmeyer/Getty To this day, Kirsten Dunst’s portrayal of Mary Jane in Sam Raimi’s “Spider-Man” trilogy remains one of the most iconic roles in superhero movie history. But there was ... Read more »

Epstein housekeeper describes finding sex toy after massages

Juan Alessi, Jeffrey Epstein’s house manager, testified about finding and cleaning sex toys while working for Epstein at Ghislaine Maxwell’s trial on Dec. 2, 2021. REUTERS/Jane Rosenberg Jeffrey Epstein’s former ... Read more »

Planned obsolescence: Apple set to ‘kill off' older iPhone models

The iPhone 6 Plus could be designated on Apple’s “vintage products” list on Dec. 31, according to an internal memo. REUTERS/Michaela Rehle Apple is about to “kill off” millions of ... Read more »

Arrest made in Jacqueline Avant slaying after suspect shoots himself in foot

Jacqueline Avant, Clarence Avant‘s wife, was fatally shot early Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2021. Mark Von Holden Invision/AP, File The man suspected of murdering music legend Clarence Avant’s wife at her ... Read more »

Jussie Smollett's lawyers claim judge ‘lunged' at one of them, ask for a mistrial

Jussie Smollett’s attorneys are demanding a mistrial after Judge James Linn deemed some evidence as irrelevant. AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast CHICAGO — Jussie Smollett’s attorneys asked for a mistrial Thursday ... Read more »

‘Arthur might still be alive if social services listened to my warnings about Emma Tustin', says her ex boyfriend

EMMA Tustin's ex-boyfriend claimed Arthur Labinjo-Hughes would still be alive if social services had listened to his warnings about her. Tustin, 32, and Arthur's dad Thomas, 29, were convicted of ... Read more »

Kelly Clarkson breaks down in tears over ‘feeling alone' during Christmas special amid Brandon Blackstock divorce

KELLY Clarkson broke down in tears during her Christmas special on Wednesday while admitting she’s been “feeling along” amid her divorce. The 39-year-old, who split from her husband last year, ... Read more »

Nurse gets 10 years for sex assault of incapacitated woman

The Associated PressFILE – This undated photo provided by Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office shows Nathan Sutherland, who was sentenced to 10 years in prison on Thursday, Dec. 2, 2021, for ... Read more »

House passes short-term funding bill, now up to Senate to avert shutdown

House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer criticized some congress members for failing “to act responsibly.” REUTERS/Evelyn Hockstein House Democrats kicked the can of government funding down the road another 2 1/2 ... Read more »

Letters to the Editor — Dec. 3, 2021

A group of 40 thieves stormed a Louis Vuitton store, seen above, smashing windows and grabbing merchandise before escaping in waiting cars. AP The Issue: The rash of attacks by ... Read more »

At least 5 cases of Omicron variant reported in New York

Gov. Hochul said there are now a total of five confirmed cases in the state. NYC Mayor The COVID-19 omicron variant has been detected in multiple cases in New York ... Read more »

Nine e-scooter riders died in crashes this year and ‘hundreds of thousands' of them are used illegally

NINE e-scooter riders have died in crashes this year, a report found — as “hundreds of thousands” of them are being used illegally. There were at least 300 casualties involving ... Read more »

France FINALLY admits it could take back Channel migrants – if EU states agree

FRANCE has finally admitted it could take back migrants arriving in Britain on small boats — but only if other EU nations agree. French Prime Minister Jean Castex told Boris ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity fans have same complaint over drinking challenge with Naughty Boy and Frankie Bridge – did you spot it?

I'M A Celebrity fans all had the same complaint over the drinking challenge with Naughty Boy and Frankie Bridge tonight – but did you spot it? The pair took part ... Read more »

The European Union is considering the approval of a new corona vaccine from Valneva

The European Medicines Agency (EMA) is now considering approving a corona vaccine from the French-Austrian company Valneva. The EMA committee has started the review of VLA2001, a COVID-19 vaccine under ... Read more »

From Christmas cocktails to hot chocolate – festive drink deals to tickle your taste buds for less

IT’S party season – and that means drinks all round to celebrate. Whether you are after a Crimbo cocktail, a festive ale or wine to share with friends, there are ... Read more »

Little Mix cut Jesy Nelson out of break up announcement after she quit the band to go solo

LITTLE Mix cut Jesy Nelson out of a video celebrating their 10 years together as they announced they are taking a break. The girl group revealed they're going on hiatus ... Read more »

Psaki claims COVID is ‘root cause' for wave of looting incidents

White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki on Thursday said the COVID-19 pandemic is “a root cause” of recent organized looting incidents across the country. Psaki gave the surprising remark when ... Read more »

NBR Awards name 'Licorice Pizza' its best film of 2021

The Associated PressThis image released by MGM shows Cooper Hoffman, left, and Alana Haim in a scene from “Licorice Pizza.” The National Board of Review named the “Licorice Pizza” as ... Read more »

Boyfriend arrested after girlfriend found ‘beaten to a bloody pulp' during trip to Cancun

Sativa Transue’s boyfriend is accused of beating her to death in Cancun, Mexico. Instagram A Washington state woman was found dead in her swanky hotel room in Cancun after she ... Read more »

‘Blue Rush' Podcast Episode 89: Jones or No Jones For Giants? feat. Reggie Ragland

The Daniel Jones injury saga this week has been bizarre. From “week-to-week” to him practicing and potentially starting Sunday in Miami. What is going on? Can the Giants win with ... Read more »

Hermes accused of refusing to reimburse thousands of customers after packages go missing

PARCEL giant Hermes has been accused of refusing to reimburse thousands of customers when packages go missing. Campaigners claim the firm puts up a series of “obstacles” to avoid claims. ... Read more »

Paul McCartney's daughter Stella slammed over £70 Beatles socks

STELLA McCartney’s new fashion line should come with the message, “Can’t Buy Me, Love” — due to the sky-high prices. Sir Paul’s daughter has launched a “Get Back” collection, with ... Read more »

What is the ‘Virgin error C133' code?

VIRGIN Media customers may currently be getting C133 error message when they try and use their TV services. This code indicates there is a problem connecting to the company’s services. ... Read more »

How to reboot my Virgin Media TiVO box

VIRGIN Media has crashed leaving thousands of customers unable to watch TV. According to Downdetector, there were 17,100 reports of outages at around 11am this morning (December 2, 2021). Find ... Read more »

Mistletoe doubles in price to £16.99 because of topsy-turvy weather

MISTLETOE has soared in price because of the topsy-turvy weather. One sprig can cost £16.99 — double the price in 2016. Christmas kissers now face higher prices at online marketplaces ... Read more »

Wicked dad and stepmum GUILTY of killing Arthur Labinjo-Hughes, 6, who was starved, poisoned and tortured to death

A TWISTED dad and stepmum have today been found guilty of killing a six-year-old boy who was poisoned and tortured to death. Thomas Hughes, 29, and Emma Tustin, 32, waged ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic