Proposed Holyrood legislation aims to improve outcomes for children involved in the Scottish criminal justice system. However, there are concerns about the effect of the new law on freedom of expression and open justice.
Justice must be seen to be done, even in cases involving children – Baktosch Gillan
Safeguards to protect children and promote rehabilitation are to be welcomed. The Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Bill, progressing through the Scottish Parliament, changes the definition of a “child” and raises the age at which a young person can be referred to the Children’s Hearing System to 18. This means most 16- and 17-year-olds will be referred to the specialist children’s tribunal rather than the adult justice system.
From an open justice perspective, however, a tension arises where the Bill seeks to introduce new restrictions on media reporting of cases involving children, and which could restrict publication of matters of public interest concerning adults.
The Bill makes it an offence to publish information likely to lead to the identification of a person suspected of committing an offence when they were under 18.
A perhaps unintended consequence is that someone disclosing on social media or to the press that they had been the victim of an offence would breach the legislation. A newspaper exposing bullying or historic abuse in schools, would be unable to name the institution involved – a perverse outcome arguably contrary to the right to freedom of expression under the European Convention on Human Rights, with a potentially chilling effect on investigative reporting.
Proposed amendments seek to address anomalies that could arise, but the Bill will also place additional restrictions on reports of criminal proceedings involving children.
It is currently an offence to include information in a newspaper report or broadcast calculated to lead to the identification of an under 18 as the accused, victim or witness in criminal proceedings.
The Bill goes further, however, so identifying information about an accused person must not be published if the accused was under 18 at the date of the alleged offence.
The new restrictions will also mean where the accused was under 18 and the proceedings end with an acquittal or are discontinued, the restrictions apply for their lifetime – meaning lifelong anonymity.
“What’s in a name?”, one might reasonably ask. The answer can be found in the 2010 Supreme Court case, In re Guardian News and Media Ltd.
News without names is sterile. The media are the means through which justice is seen to be done. If the media choose not to, or are unable to, challenge reporting restrictions, they are less likely to cover a trial.
Concealing the identity of the accused could erode public confidence in the administration of justice. Scrutiny of the courts and informed debate about criminal justice will suffer.
Scottish media are accustomed to and, by their own codes of practice, committed to complying with restrictions on reporting of cases concerning children. They rarely apply for restrictions to be lifted, only in the most newsworthy cases and where public interest demands it.
Open justice is a centuries-old constitutional principle. Where there are to be exceptions, a balancing of rights and factors is necessary, but open justice should be the starting point.
The Bill lists factors that the courts should have regard to in considering whether it is in the public interest to dispense with restrictions, but freedom of expression is not among them. The scales are weighted heavily in favour of censorship and against freedom of expression.
What’s in a name? More than you might first think.
Baktosch Gillan is a commercial litigation solicitor, Thorntons Solicitors.
News Related
-
Asylum seekers travel in an inflatable boat across the English Channel, bound for Dover on the south coast of England (Photo: Ben Stansall/AFP) Up to 40 Conservative MPs are poised to rebel over Rishi Sunak’s Rwanda deportation policy as they question ministers’ commitment to the scheme. A major row is ...
See Details:
Up to 40 Tory MPs ‘set to rebel’ if Sunak’s Rwanda plan doesn’t override ECHR
-
In the saltmarsh fringing where the Ballyboe River dissolves into Trawbreaga Bay, a little egret wears its plumage like a windblown stole. Our car swoops across the 10 arches of Malin bridge and we park along the village green. Malin is almost as far north as you can get on ...
See Details:
Country diary: A tale of three churches
-
Photograph: Chris Ratcliffe/EPA Hampton Court is an enduring monument to the power of Henry VIII, a pleasure palace down the Thames from Westminster and the City of London. On Monday it was the scene of power projection of a different kind, as Rishi Sunak pitched for investment from some of ...
See Details:
Sunak woos business elite with royal welcome – but they seek certainty
-
-
Tottenham interested in move to sign “fearless” £20m defender in January Tottenham Hotspur have joined the race to bring an overseas defender to the Premier League in January, according to a fresh report. Postecoglou’s centre-back options The Lilywhites currently have Micky Van De Ven, Ashley Phillips, Cristian Romero and Eric ...
See Details:
Tottenham interested in move to sign “fearless” £20m defender in January
-
A £100m campaign urging households and businesses to use less water will be funded from customers’ bills, Ofwat has said. Bill payers to stump up cost of £100m water usage campaign The regulator’s chief executive David Black told MPs that if the measures worked it would be cheaper than building ...
See Details:
Bill payers to stump up cost of £100m water usage campaign
-
FILE PHOTO: Soccer Football – FIFA Women’s World Cup Australia and New Zealand 2023 – Group B – Canada Training – Olympic Park, Melbourne, Australia – July 24, 2023 Canada’s Christine Sinclair during training REUTERS/Hannah Mckay/File Photo (Reuters) – BC Place in Vancouver, British Columbia, will be renamed “Christine Sinclair ...
See Details:
Soccer-Venue renamed 'Christine Sinclair Place' for Canada soccer great's final game
-
Michael van Gerwen is hunting down a fourth World Championship title (Picture: Getty Images) Michael van Gerwen is Phil Taylor’s tip to lift the World Darts Championship trophy for a fourth time in January, expecting a backlash from the recent defeat in the Players Championship Finals. The 2024 World Championship ...
See Details:
Phil Taylor makes his pick for 2024 World Darts Championship winner
-
Michael van Gerwen is hunting down a fourth World Championship title (Picture: Getty Images) Michael van Gerwen is Phil Taylor’s tip to lift the World Darts Championship trophy for a fourth time in January, expecting a backlash from the recent defeat in the Players Championship Finals. The 2024 World Championship ...
See Details:
Soccer-Howe aims to boost Newcastle's momentum in PSG clash
-
Michael van Gerwen is hunting down a fourth World Championship title (Picture: Getty Images) Michael van Gerwen is Phil Taylor’s tip to lift the World Darts Championship trophy for a fourth time in January, expecting a backlash from the recent defeat in the Players Championship Finals. The 2024 World Championship ...
See Details:
Hamilton heads for hibernation with a word of warning
-
Michael van Gerwen is hunting down a fourth World Championship title (Picture: Getty Images) Michael van Gerwen is Phil Taylor’s tip to lift the World Darts Championship trophy for a fourth time in January, expecting a backlash from the recent defeat in the Players Championship Finals. The 2024 World Championship ...
See Details:
Carolina Panthers fire head coach Frank Reich after 1-10 start to the season
-
Michael van Gerwen is hunting down a fourth World Championship title (Picture: Getty Images) Michael van Gerwen is Phil Taylor’s tip to lift the World Darts Championship trophy for a fourth time in January, expecting a backlash from the recent defeat in the Players Championship Finals. The 2024 World Championship ...
See Details:
This exercise is critical for golfers. 4 tips to doing it right
-
Michael van Gerwen is hunting down a fourth World Championship title (Picture: Getty Images) Michael van Gerwen is Phil Taylor’s tip to lift the World Darts Championship trophy for a fourth time in January, expecting a backlash from the recent defeat in the Players Championship Finals. The 2024 World Championship ...
See Details:
One in three households with children 'will struggle to afford Christmas'
-
OTHER NEWS
Kobbie Mainoo made his first start for Man Utd at Everton (Photo: Getty) The Football Association are reportedly confident that Manchester United starlet Kobbie Mainoo will choose to represent England ...
Read more »
Michael Smith will begin the defence of his world title on the opening night (Picture: Getty Images) The 2024 World Darts Championship is less than three weeks away and the ...
Read more »
For the first time a long haul commercial aircraft is flying across the Atlantic using 100% sustainable aviation fuel (SAF). A long haul commercial flight is flying to the US ...
Read more »
The King has met business and finance leaders from across the world at a Buckingham Palace reception to mark the conclusion of the UK’s Global Investment Summit. Charles was introduced ...
Read more »
After Ohio State’s 30-24 loss to Michigan Saturday, many college football fans were wondering where Lou Holtz was. In his postgame interview after the Buckeyes beat Notre Dame 17-14 in ...
Read more »
Darius Slay wouldn’t have minded being penalized on controversial no-call No matter which team you were rooting for on Sunday, we can all agree that the officiating job performed by ...
Read more »
New England Patriots quarterback Mac Jones (10) Quarterback Mac Jones remains committed to finding success with the New England Patriots even though his future is up in the air following ...
Read more »