A response, based on the actual law, to Panda's copy-and-paste letter for workers who wish to not disclose their vaccination status

Your job and the Covid-19 vaccine explained.

A response, based on the actual law, to Panda’s copy-and-paste letter for workers who wish to not disclose their vaccination status
© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

President Cyril Ramaphosa, in his speech on 28 November, reiterated the importance of vaccination in dealing with the pandemic. He implored all eligible people to get vaccinated and announced that a Governmental Task Team is assessing the possibility of mandatory vaccination for certain areas and/or activities.

The question of mandatory vaccination is one that employers have been grappling with, and which employers are legally empowered to implement — although not without detractors.

A team of lawyers from Webber Wentzel has considered the “Workplace Medical Disclosure Letter — South Africa” recently shared by Panda (Pandemics Data & Analytics).

In broad terms the letter suggests a template response that an employee could use stating that their vaccination status is private, and that they cannot be compelled to disclose their vaccination status.

The Panda letter aims to couch the employee objection within both law and science and offers objecting employees the ability to download a letter response to their employees with several arguments it has prepared on their behalf. Although employees are certainly free to raise the arguments put forward by Panda, employees seeking to use these arguments should note the following:

  • It is incorrect to say that employees cannot be compelled to disclose their medical status. By law this may be required in appropriate circumstances, and this is not unique to Covid-19 vaccination status. In any event, the requirement is not that employees disclose their medical status (they may voluntarily seek to do so in any refusal to be vaccinated) — all that is required is for them to disclose their vaccination status. The distinction is important in law.
  • Every employer has a statutory duty to safeguard the health of their employees while they are at work — many of whom may have comorbidities. The courts have already held that: “There is no bright line between public health and occupational health… the Covid-19 pandemic presents both a public health concern and a[n] occupational health concern. It is a risk for the entire nation. But it presents particular risks and requires particular responses in workplaces…”. There is a significant amount of credible and peer reviewed medical and scientific information available which refutes the medical and scientific information set out in the Panda letter. Many employers are likely to have considered this information and reasonably based their Covid vaccination policies on reputable sources of medical and scientific advice.
  • It is incorrect that the measures that have previously been taken to address other diseases (like HIV, TB or flu) are sufficient to meet the reasonability standard imposed under the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA). HIV cannot be spread simply by being in casual, workplace-appropriate, contact with others and neither TB nor flu have, in recent years at least, ever been categorised as a pandemic. Applying legal principles based on workplace management of these diseases to measures intended to prevent and mitigate the spread of Covid-19 in a workplace is egregious. Also, regarding the statement that Covid-19 vaccines are still in a trial phase and as “research or experimentation on a living person” is incorrect factually — the US Food and Drug Administration has in fact recently approved both the Moderna and Pfizer-BioNTech Covid-19 vaccines and its approval for emergency use in South Africa (as is the case) is entirely legitimate and scientifically rigorous.  This process is used in the context of a public health emergency (such as this is) to accelerate approvals of proven interventions, not to further experiment.
  • Returning to the standards imposed by OHSA, the OHSA standard expressly requires an employer to reassess risks and control measures as new information becomes available and to take measures based on the severity and the scope of the hazard. This alone requires a differentiated approach for employers managing Covid-19. An employer is required to assess the risks to which all employees and the business may be exposed and implement appropriate controls as far as possible. In the face of an available, approved control measure that mitigates harm to employees like vaccination, an employer failing to consider the need to apply this control measure in its workplace will be in breach of its common law, and statutory duties.
  • Although rights to privacy and to bodily integrity are entrenched in the Constitution, the law also recognises that rights may be limited in certain circumstances. Also, importantly, no employees “are punished” as suggested for refusing to vaccinate or refusing to provide their vaccination status. Where this position is adopted by an employee, and the basis of such objection is justifiable, the employer will (and must) seek to reasonably accommodate that employee — see more about this below. Termination of employment will only be contemplated if no accommodation can be found or if the employee refuses to accept the accommodation measures.
  • For an employer to apply a lawful and reasonable policy requiring employees to be vaccinated against Covid-19, an employer will need to know whether its employees are vaccinated or not. This will require the disclosure of private medical information. This information is, however, protected by both the right to privacy in the Constitution (section 14) and by the Protection of Personal Information Act (Popia).
  • Popia was enacted specifically to protect personal information, but also to identify the justifiable limitations on that right. An employee who seeks to rely on the right to privacy must first rely on Popia and cannot directly rely on the Constitution. As vaccination status relates to the health/medical status of an employee, it amounts to Special Personal Information under Popia and may only be processed by an employer in limited circumstances. These circumstances include, where an employer obtains the informed, voluntary, and specific consent of the employee or where the processing of the personal information is necessary for the establishment, exercise, or defence of a right or obligation in law. Following from this, Popia contemplates that, despite an employee’s right to privacy, an employer may request its employees to disclose their vaccination status, to uphold the employer’s occupational health and safety obligations. Further, while employers have a reasonable and lawful basis on which to request vaccination information, if an employee refuses to provide this, the employer may elect to manage this practically by accepting that refusal and regarding such persons as unvaccinated for purposes of any policy.
  • Related to the constitutional arguments put forward, while an employer is required to uphold the right to privacy, bodily integrity, equality, and the right to freedom of conscience, religion, thought, belief, and opinion — these rights are not absolute. They may be limited by a law of general application in instances where it is fair and justifiable to do so. A limitations analysis requires a consideration of the nature of the right; the importance of the purpose of the limitation; the nature and extent of the limitation; the relation between the limitation and its purpose; and whether there are less restrictive means to achieve the purpose. It is important to note, first, that the OHSA is a law of general application, and second that although no court has yet ruled on this issue, several top constitutional experts (both within Webber Wentzel and outside of the firm) have expressly stated that they take the view that a mandatory vaccine policy by an employer within the context of managing and mitigating the spread of Covid-19 infection is almost certain to pass constitutional scrutiny by the courts.
  • Although the Labour Relations Act (LRA) protects an employee from being dismissed if the reason for the dismissal is that the employer discriminated against the employee, Section 187(1)(f) of the LRA which the Panda letter refers to can only be relied upon if employment is terminated and based on unfair discrimination. If an employee refuses to share their vaccination status, the employer will assume that the employee is unvaccinated and apply the policy consistently — unfair discrimination cannot be claimed in this instance.

Also, what the Panda letter doesn’t set out, which may be useful to employees in this situation, is that an employer must by law reasonably accommodate an employee who refuses vaccination.

Refusals in this instance may be based on medical or constitutional grounds. The reason for the refusal must be assessed by the employer to determine the veracity of the employee’s refusal and its reasonableness and, only where the refusal is determined to be justifiable, should steps be taken to reasonably accommodate that employee.

Such accommodation may take many forms. It is only in instances in which reasonable accommodation is not possible, or when the employee refuses to accept the reasonable accommodation, that it may be appropriate to terminate the employment of the employee. Depending on the circumstances, termination may be based on either incapacity, operational requirements or, in less limited instances, misconduct. In each instance, the employer must comply with the requirements of the Code of Good Practice, Dismissal (schedule 8 to the LRA).

Our advice to employees in this scenario who do not want to disclose their vaccination status? Don’t copy and paste a letter from the internet with several factual and legal inaccuracies.

Consider and formulate your own personally held views and beliefs in relation to any vaccination policy (or disclosure of vaccination status) and present these to your employer in the form of a “refusal to be vaccinated”.

Then work with your employer constructively in assessing and validating the reasons and determining ways in which these may be reasonably accommodated.

This approach avoids unnecessary antagonism, and enables an employer to comply with its lawful obligations to all of its employees in what are unprecedented and challenging times for all.

It is our experience that employers are committed to a fair and principled implementation of the policy and will seek to engage constructively with employees. Such engagement may get off on the wrong foot if the Panda letter is the catalyst. DM

Webber Wentzel is a leading full-service law firm operating on the African continent.

[hearken id=”daily-maverick/8881″]

News Related


Routine eye tests can flag up people at risk of a heart attack

A routine eye test at the opticians could be used to flag patients at risk of having a heart attack, a study suggests.  Scientists have developed an AI programme that ... Read more »

Nadhim Zahawi announces crackdown on school attendance ‘postcode lottery'

Education Secretary Nadhim Zahawi has vowed to end a “postcode lottery” on school absence across the country, in what will be a “key component” of his Schools White Paper expected ... Read more »

Julie Dalton, owner of Hatch, St Andrews, tell us about her dream dinner guests and guilty food pleasure

Hatch opened last year, as a sister venue to The Adamson next door © Julie Dalton What’s your favourite ingredient? Black pepper, as it’s the king of spices and divine ... Read more »

Where to find a pizza party item in Fortnite Chapter 3 Season 1

© Provided by GamePur Unlike most of the food you’ll discover in Fortnite Chapter 3 Season 1, the pizza party item is debatably the best you can possibly find. This ... Read more »

Scottish independence: SNP's new push for a second referendum despite ongoing Covid crisis is the last thing we need – Alex Cole-Hamilton MSP

© A return to a divisive referendum campaign will not help Scotland deal with Covid and its wider effe… Things like the roll-out of state-funded childcare, efforts to address the ... Read more »

China to allow gene-edited crops in push for food security

A farmer plants seeds in a corn field at a farm in Gaocheng, Hebei province, China, September 30, 2015. REUTERS BEIJING, Jan 25 – China has published trial rules for ... Read more »

Monaco's Charlotte Casiraghi rides a horse on Chanel runway at Paris Fashion Week

Grace Kelly’s granddaughter, Charlotte Casiraghi of Monaco, made quite the entrance as she rode a horse on the Chanel runway at Paris Fashion Week on Tuesday. Chanel’s Haute Couture Spring/Summer ... Read more »

Florian Marku signs with Sky Sports and BOXXER

Florian Marku will continue to thrill fans on Sky Sports Florian ‘The Albanian King’ Marku has signed a new long-term promotional agreement with BOXXER as he continues his pursuit for ... Read more »

How to join and leave a Guild in Guild Wars 2

© Provided by GamePur Guilds bring a social aspect to the game that brings together people from around the world to unite towards common goals. The tricky thing is recruiting ... Read more »

'Nightmares', 'Moshiri, I swear to God' - Many Everton fans horrified by fresh Martinez report

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Roberto Martinez at Euro 2020 Roberto Martinez could still end up being appointed Everton manager for a second time.  The Mirror‘s David Maddock wrote that ... Read more »

New shows for Beth Rigby, Sophy Ridge and Trevor Phillips in Sky shake-up

Sky is launching new programmes hosted by Beth Rigby, Sophy Ridge and Trevor Phillips to highlight “lively debate, discussion and opinion,” the broadcaster has announced. In the shake-up, Sky News’ ... Read more »

IMF slashes global growth forecast due to Omicron, inflation

The International Monetary Fund has downgraded its global growth forecast for 2022. AFP via Getty Images The International Monetary Fund cut its global growth forecast for 2022 due to slowing ... Read more »

Fauci says 'prudent' to have Omicron vaccine, but may not be needed

© (photo credit: J. SCOTT APPLEWHITE/REUTERS) TOP INFECTIOUS disease expert Dr. Anthony Fauci responds to accusations by Sen. Rand Paul during testimony before the US Senate Health, Education, Labor, and ... Read more »

Apex Legends players collide in gravity cannon, immediately duel

© Provided by Dot Esports The last place you expect to duel in Apex Legends is at the top of a gravity cannon’s arc. But that’s exactly what happened to ... Read more »

Liverpool fan posts eye-opening video of VAR decisions from 20/21 after dodgy penalty v Palace

Liverpool‘s 3-1 victory away at Crystal Palace last Sunday was shrouded in controversy. In the latter stages of the match when things were most certainly in the balance, the Reds ... Read more »

Fall Guys Monopoly is now available

© Provided by Dot Esports Fall Guys fans can now enjoy the colorful and unique gameplay from Mediatonic’s smash hit in Monopoly with Fall Guys Monopoly.  Monopoly is one of ... Read more »

Attacks on the UAE: 'A new chapter has begun in the Yemen conflict'

© AFP (illustration) One week after a first attack on the United Arab Emirates, Yemen’s Iran-backed Houthi rebels fired ballistic missiles at Abu Dhabi and Dubai on Monday. The attacks mark a ... Read more »

‘You pack of wet lettuces' – Furious Tyson Fury takes aim at heavyweight rivals

Tyson Fury has branded rivals Anthony Joshua Dillian Whyte and Oleksandr Usyk “wet lettuces” and “cowards” – among other things – in a series of foul-mouthed videos. Fury, the WBC ... Read more »

How to create a Guild in Guild Wars 2

© Provided by GamePur There’s nothing better than having a place to call home, particularly in a game where there are so many areas and random players doing their own ... Read more »

Ghosts Season 2: CBS comedy series gets the greenlight for second outing

Breakout sitcom, Ghosts, has been renewed for a second season on CBS as part of its 2022-2023 comedy line-up.  The show has been adapted from the British BBC sitcom, also titled Ghosts, ... Read more »

'I went for coffee in a London toilet and I'll definitely drink out of a urinal again'

Oxford Street can sometimes get a little too much for Londoners. Elbowing past tourists and trying to avoid crowds is exhausting, so where is the perfect place to have a ... Read more »

American Idol has BTS shake-up ahead of new series - all the details

American Idol is undergoing a major shift ahead of its season five premiere, which might look a lot different. MORE: Luke Bryan’s children star in emotional new video Veteran showrunner Trish ... Read more »

Camilla hails domestic abuse charity as it marks 50 years

The Duchess of Cornwall has called for domestic abuse campaigners to carry on their vital work, after an explosion in demand for specialist services during the pandemic. As the charity ... Read more »

Woman stabbed in Maida Vale named as Yasmin Chkaifi

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: James Veysey/REX/Shutterstock A woman who was stabbed to death in Maida Vale, London, on Monday has been named as Yasmin Chkaifi. Chkaifi, 43, also ... Read more »

Chelsea sent clear transfer warning as Ousmane Dembele in London for 'crucial meeting'

We are now into the final week of the January transfer window and time is running out for Chelsea to complete any late deals. However, it’s understood that Thomas Tuchel ... Read more »

Pearce: Wantaway Man Utd star would ‘no doubt' improve West Ham

© PA Images West-Ham-coach-Stuart-Pearce Stuart Pearce has admitted that Manchester United midfielder Jesse Lingard is someone who would improve West Ham United. Lingard had a spell on loan at the ... Read more »

Liverpool ‘blow up everything' for Real as Klopp makes star a promise

© PA Images Jurgen Klopp looks delighted after winning a match Jurgen Klopp has guaranteed Borussia Monchengladbach Denis Zakaria a regular starting berth if he joins Liverpool over Real Madrid, ... Read more »

‘Thierry Henry of the third division' – These Sheff Wed fans react to transfer arrival

© Provided by Football League World Carabao Cup First Round – Sheffield Wednesday v Huddersfield Town Sheffield Wednesday have announced the signing of Tyreece John-Jules from Arsenal on a loan ... Read more »

Tyson's Heart-Shaped Chicken Nuggets Are Back, and Available in Stores This Valentine's Day

A year ago to the day, Tyson announced that it had created heart-shaped chicken nuggets for a Valentine’s Day surprise. The only downside was that you had to enter a ... Read more »

Cure for sanctimonious Hollywood? Let Ricky Gervais host the Oscars

Ricky Gervais might be the only person who can save the Academy Awards from flopping like the 2021 Golden Globes. Paul Drinkwater/NBCUniversal Media, LLC via Getty Images If Hollywood wants ... Read more »

Horror-Verdacht in Mexiko: Drogen in Babyleiche in den Knast geschmuggelt?

Ein totes Baby wurde in einem mexikanischen Gefängnis gefunden. Möglicherweise um Drogen in den Knast zu schmuggeln. Die Hintergründe sind unklar. Die Polizei hat 21 Personen festgenommen. © Bereitgestellt von ... Read more »

Unruhen in Myanmar: Junta droht Demonstranten mit Anklagen wegen Hochverrats

Knapp ein Jahr nach dem Militärputsch in Myanmar hat die Junta Demonstranten mit Anklagen wegen Hochverrats gedroht. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Junta droht Demonstranten mit Anklagen wegen Hochverrats Wer im ... Read more »

Mysteriöser Krankheitsverlauf, denn Bub hatte keine Vorerkrankungen: Zehnjähriger in Turin an Corona gestorben

Der Tod eines italienischen Jungen auf der Intensivstation des Turiner Kinderspitals gibt Rätsel auf. Verzweifelt versuchten Ärzte, den kleinen Corona-Patienten zu retten. Vergebens. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Zehnjähriger in Turin ... Read more »

‘Evil and sadistic' girl, 16, ‘laughed as she tortured a doctor to death in a city centre park'

A “SADISTIC” teenage girl “laughed as she tortured a doctor to death in a city centre park,” a court has heard. The 16-year-old girl, who was described as “evil and ... Read more »

A tribute to Shamita Shetty by Tejaswi Prakash on Bigg Boss 15

© Provided by The Statesman A tribute to Shamita Shetty by Tejaswi Prakash on Bigg Boss 15 With the finale of ‘Bigg Boss 15’ just around the corner, the contestants ... Read more »

'Devastating' setback for women's game

O. Bembem Devi had switched on the television at 7.30pm on Sunday. The former India captain was hoping to see how the team fares against Chinese Taipei after the draw ... Read more »

Padma Awards 2022 List ANNOUNCED: Sonu Nigam, Victor Banerjee, Chandraprakash Dwivedi to be honoured

© Provided by Pinkvilla Actor Victor Banerjee, musician Sonu Nigam, and filmmaker Chandraprakash Dwivedi will be honoured for their contributions in the field of arts at the Padma Awards for ... Read more »

Ukraine thwarts destabilization plot by Russian-backed crime group: officials

Ukrainian security officials announced Tuesday they had stopped an attempt by a Russian-backed crime organization to destabilize the country amid worries of an invasion by Moscow. Kiev’s SBU security service ... Read more »

Five false flags Putin could use to spark Ukraine war from staged chemical attacks to Hitler's invasion playbook

RUSSIA is feared to be plotting to use a false flag event as cover to justify an invasion of Ukraine. US intelligence warned that Vladimir Putin could shamelessly manufacture the ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic