A journal of plans to kill, warnings from teachers and a chilling ‘countdown': The red flags around alleged Michigan school shooter Ethan Crumbley

Ethan Crumbley seen in his booking photo following his arrest (AP)

As the tight-knit community of Oxford Township, Michigan, struggles to pick up the pieces from a deadly high school shooting, revelations about multiple red flags from the days prior are fuelling an impossible question: why wasn’t something done to prevent this?

Suspect Ethan Crumbley is accused of shooting dead four classmates and wounding seven others at Oxford High School on Tuesday.

The 15-year-old sophomore is facing 24 charges including one count of terrorism and four counts of first-degree murder, which carry a maximum sentence of life in prison.

Investigators reportedly uncovered a “mountain of evidence” showing Mr Crumbley allegedly plotted his attack well in advance, outlining plans in a journal and sharing his intentions in two videos filmed before the shooting.

His social media accounts were allegedly studded with menacing posts, including a photo of the handgun he used in his rampage and an apparent countdown warning: “Now I become death – destroyer of worlds – see you tomorrow Oxford.”

Teachers at Oxford High School raised concerns about the teen’s behaviour twice in the days leading up to the shooting, authorities say. The second time took place on the morning of the shooting, when Mr Crumbley’s parents met with him and administrators at the school.

Details about the behaviour that prompted those concerns remain unclear, but they were serious enough for Oakland County Prosecutor Karen McDonald to question why Mr Crumbley was allowed to return to class after the meeting.

Follow live updates on the Michigan school shooting

Students and parents described a sense of unease on the campus in the weeks prior, saying that threats of a violence had been circulating for some time. The school acknowledged the rumours in a letter to parents in mid-November.

When pieced together, these details paint a picture that casts doubt on claims by school administrators and law enforcement that they had no prior knowledge of what would come to take place on Tuesday.

‘Desire to kill’

Gunshots rang out in the halls of Oxford High School just before 1pm, sending students scrambling for cover as they’d been taught in routine active shooter drills.

Surveillance video purportedly showed Mr Crumbley emerging from a bathroom with a 9mm Sig Sauer SP2022 semi-automatic handgun. Prosecutors said he fired the gun “methodically” but appeared to be targeting people at random.

Officers from more than 60 law enforcement agencies in the area responded to the scene and took Mr Crumbley into custody within five minutes of the first shots.

In those five minutes, Mr Crumbley fired at least 30 rounds, police said. There were still 18 rounds in his gun when he surrendered.

Three students – Tate Myre, 16; Madisyn Baldwin, 17; and Hana St Juliana, 14 – were pronounced dead at the scene and a fourth, 17-year-old Justin Shilling, died in hospital the next day. A further six students and one teacher were injured.

The carnage which seemed unimaginable to students, parents and community members who watched it unfold was exactly what Mr Crumbley intended, according to prosecutors.

Details about his alleged plans for the attack emerged at his arraignment on Wednesday.

Lt Tim Willis of the Oakland County Sheriff’s office said investigators found two videos on Mr Crumbley’s cell phone in which he talked about shooting and killing students at the high school.

They also found a journal in his backpack which described his “desire to shoot up the school to include murdering students”, Mr Willis said.

Mr Crumbley’s Instagram page reportedly featured a photo of the handgun he used in the shooting, with the caption: “Just got my new beauty today.” His father, James Crumbley, reportedly purchased the gun on Black Friday.

Ms McDonald, the Oakland County prosecutor, highlighted another “disturbing” and “troubling” piece of evidence at a press conference on Wednesday, but said she could not yet disclose what it was.

She said investigators are still sifting through evidence but have thus far have zero doubt that the attack was premeditated. “I am absolutely sure after reviewing the evidence that it isn’t even a close call, it was absolutely premeditated,” she said.

Parents under scrutiny

Ms McDonald said investigators are working to determine whether Mr Crumbley’s parents, Jennifer and James Crumbley, knew of his plans for the attack. She said her office is still weighing the possibility of charges against the pair.

They were, however, aware of concerns about his behaviour in the days prior, according to Oakland County Sheriff Michael Bouchard.

Mr Bouchard said two teachers separately reported concerning behaviour from Mr Crumbley, first on the day before the shooting and again on the day it happened.

The first came when “a teacher in the classroom where he was a student saw and heard something that she felt was disturbing”, Mr Bouchard told CNN.

“They had a counselling session about it with school officials, and a phone call was left with the parents,” he added.

The following day, a different teacher “saw behaviour they felt was concerning” and called Mr Crumbley into a meeting with school officials, which his parents also joined.

Mr Crumbley was allowed to return to class after the meeting. Just hours later, he opened fire.

Jennifer and James Crumbley are seen during their son’s arraignment on Wednesday (Rochester Hills District Court)

After he was taken into custody, Mr Crumbley’s parents refused to give investigators permission to speak to him, authorities said. They appeared at his arraignment via video, but did not say anything.

A cache of weapons was seized from the family’s home after the shooting, including several long guns.

Jennifer Crumbley, a real estate broker in Oxford, shared enthusiasm for guns in an open letter to Donald Trump in November 2016 after he was elected president.

“As a female and a Realtor, thank you for allowing my right to bear arms,” the 43-year-old wrote. “Allowing me to be protected if I show a home to someone with bad intentions. Thank you for respecting that Amendment.”

James Crumbley, a 45-year-old tech salesman, shared the letter on social media and wrote: “My wife can be spot on.”

Ms McDonald did not say whether investigators believe the parents knew their son had taken the handgun on the day of the shooting, or if he did so without permission.

Under Michigan law, the parents of a child who violates firearm-related statutes on school property or in a school vehicle can be held criminally liable if the parent knew the child’s intentions or furthered their actions.

As for whether charges will be filed against the parents, Ms McDonald said: “We know that owning a gun means securing it properly and locking it and keeping the ammunition separate and not allowing access to other individuals, particularly minors. We know that and we have to hold individuals accountable who don’t do that.”

Trouble on campus

Administrators at the school have also faced scrutiny over their handling of concerns about Mr Crumbley’s behaviour, as well as their response to rumours of violence on campus.

Speaking to reporters soon after the shooting, Oxford Community Schools Superintendent Tim Throne insisted the school had no prior knowledge of the attack.

As panicked parents rushed to locate their children in the chaos after the shooting, one mother claimed that her son had expressed serious concern about trouble brewing on the campus hours earlier.

Robin Redding told the Associated Press her son Treshan Bryant, a 12th grader at the school, opted to stay home on Tuesday because he and his younger cousins had a “bad feeling” that violence could be coming.

Mr Bryant told the outlet he had heard vague threats about plans for a shooting “for a long time now”.

“You’re not supposed to play about that,” he said. “This is real life.”

While investigators have yet to determine a motive for the shooting, Ms Redding said: “This couldn’t be just random.”

Ms Redding didn’t offer details about what her son had heard but shared general concern with safety at the school.

“Kids just, like they’re just mad at each other at this school,” she said.

People mourn at a growing memorial outside Oxford High School (EPA)

It later emerged that school officials had sent a vague letter to parents dismissing the existence of safety threats on campus three weeks earlier.

“We are aware of the numerous rumors that have been circulating throughout our building this week. We understand that has created some concern for students and parents,” the letter dated 12 November stated.

“Please know that we have reviewed every concern shared with us and investigated all information provided. Some rumors have evolved from an incident last week, while others do not appear to have any connection. Student interpretations of social media posts and false information have exacerbated the overall concern.

“We want our parents and students to know there has been no threat to our building nor our students.”

Following the shooting, critics have pointed to the letter as evidence that the school knew trouble was brewing and didn’t do enough to address it.

‘Fervent hope’ for gun reform

Shockwaves from Tuesday’s shooting rippled far beyond the campus itself, as gun control advocates nationwide pointed to Oxford in renewed calls for reform.

The shooting joins a list of 28 that have taken place in US schools so far this year, according to Everytown.org.

Ms McDonald stressed the importance of learning from Oxford’s heartache during Wednesday’s press conference.

“We have watched school shootings unfold in this country for far too long,” she said. “Sadly, the national spotlight is shining today on our community.

“It’s my fervent hope that this will be the last time that we experience an incident like this in Oakland County or anywhere.”

News Related


After drama: Mariska Bauer celebrates her birthday ‘grateful and happy'

When writing a selfie Maris to be ‘grateful and happy’ on Instagram. “Fortunately, my recovery is going well and I am feeling well, thanks in part to the support of ... Read more »

'Seinfeld,' 'Law & Order: SVU,' actress Kathryn Kates dies from lung cancer at 73

Kathryn Kates, the actress who appeared in “Seinfeld” and “The Many Saints of Newark,” has died. She was 73. Her agent Ben Jordan confirmed to USA TODAY late Tuesday evening ... Read more »

It is heartbreaking and sad what has happened to Albert Verlinde since his comeback

All of a sudden they were in there last night Show news: Albert Verlinde’s no longer expected apology to Humberto Tan. For that ‘ridiculous, stupid’ (yes, Verlinde had really introspected) ... Read more »

Eva Jinek at the top of the Bestseller 60 with Dream big

Photo: ANP Eva Jinek took first place in the Bestseller 60 this week with her book Dream Big. The CPNB Foundation, which compiles the list, announced this on Wednesday. Last ... Read more »

After Peter Dinklage calls 'Snow White' plot 'backward,' Disney pledges new approach

Peter Dinklage has issues with certain “progressive” moves in the entertainment industry. (Jesse Dittmar / For The Times) Peter Dinklage has some thoughts about hypocrisy among Hollywood progressives. The “Game ... Read more »

Bollywood star cleared of obscenity charges 15 years after 'indecent' Gere kiss

A leading Bollywood actress has been formally cleared of obscenity charges which dated back to 2007. Shilpa Shetty, known globally as one of the most famous Hindu film stars, was ... Read more »

Must Read: Priyanka Chopra Covers 'Vanity Fair,' Style Heroine Is Now Sergio Rossi's Artistic Director

Plus, new report links fashion brands to company closely tied to Xinjiang. View the original article to see embedded media. These are the stories making headlines in fashion on Thursday. ... Read more »

Sun Children's screenwriters play smart games with the viewer's expectations

Sun Children School of the Sun, that’s the name of the educational institution where 12-year-old Ali attends, along with 280 other boys from the lower class of Tehran. Ali is ... Read more »

FuboTV cost and plan prices: see today's best deals

Love live sports? Then look no further than FuboTV. This online cable replacement has unbeatable worldwide sports coverage plus an impressive number of general entertainment channels. And, compared to rival ... Read more »

Mexicans protest journalist killings

Three journalists have been killed in Mexico in the last two weeks, the latest, Lordes Maldonado, shot sitting in a car over the weekend in the northern border city, Tijuana. ... Read more »

Conversation with jubilee royal couple can be seen on this site and app

One of the wedding gifts that Willem-Alexander and Máxima received at the time was the establishment of the Oranje Fonds, which supports social initiatives in the kingdom. The previously recorded ... Read more »

Disney responds to Peter Dinklage after his comments about remake of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

Disney says it is "consulting with members of the dwarfism community" on the film "to avoid reinforcing stereotypes from the original animated film". They added they were taking a "different approach with these seven characters". Read more »

Humberto Tan remains silent after Albert Verlinde apology

Verlinde accused Tan of possible transgressive behavior during Tan’s talk show RTL Late Night, which was shown on television from 2013 to 2019. Tan subsequently filed a complaint against Verlinde ... Read more »

British Summer Time 2022: When do the clocks change?

when do the clocks change uk why go forward BST British Summer Time 2022 – SEBASTIAN KAHNERT/Getty Images Contributor The warmer weather and lighter evenings will soon make a return, ... Read more »

Glenn Youngkin Set Up Tipline To Report Teachers And You Know What Pranksters Did Next

Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin’s (R) tipline to report what he describes as “divisive practices” in schools — such as the teaching of critical race theory ― has been hit with ... Read more »

Traditional phrases sent to the knacker's yard - the 50 'endangered' sayings

Traditional phrases are at risk of dying out as a survey found younger generations do not use them – Ian Nicholson/PA People who pepper their speech with traditional phrases may ... Read more »

Leicestershire teacher Sarah Moulds charged with animal cruelty over video of horse being punched and kicked

A primary school teacher has been charged with animal cruelty after a video appeared to show her punching and kicking a horse. Sarah Moulds was sacked from her position at ... Read more »

Nigella Lawson mocks Tory MP over Partygate: 'You think this is a joke?'

Boris Johnson leaves Parliament after telling MPs he welcomed a plice investigation into Partygate. (Getty) Celebrity chef Nigella Lawson has criticised a Tory MP who attempted to defend Boris Johnson ... Read more »

After Snow White criticism Dinklage: Disney enters into conversation with people with dwarfism

“To avoid reinforcing the stereotypes of the original animated film, we’re dealing with these seven characters differently and have consulted with people with dwarfism,” Disney said. Dinklage, who is best ... Read more »

Lauren Malt: Nigel Malt charged with murder of his 19-year-old daughter in Norfolk

A 44-year-old man has been charged with the murder of his teenage daughter. Nigel Malt, of Lynn Road, King's Lynn, Norfolk, is due to appear in court in Norwich on ... Read more »

On This Day: 26 January 2001

Jennifer Lopez and Matthew McConaughey shared the screen in rom com “The Wedding Planner,” as it went on general release in the U.S. (Jan. 26) Read more »

Canadians killed in Mexico over gang debt, prosecutors say

Two people, including a Canadian, have been arrested after two other Canadians were killed in a shooting at a Mexico hotel, which a prosecutor alleges was part of an assassination ... Read more »

Sound of Music continues, Aladdin and Soldier of Orange not yet

the musicals The Sound of Music and He believes in me will resume this week. Also the performances Titanic and The Rocky Horror Show are back in theaters shortly. Bigger ... Read more »

‘I had my issues': MaMkhize on why she didn't land the ‘Umkhokha' role

© Provided by The South African Royal AM owner Shauwn “MaMkhize” Mkhize opened up about why she did not land the role on Umkhokha. MAMKHIZE: ‘I HAD MY ISSUES’ The ... Read more »

Is it possible to gamble without an account

Many people like to play online games. This has led to the discovery of a new trend in online gambling sites. No account casinos are the contemporary quality in the ... Read more »

Jake Paul Invests in UFC, Reveals Plans To Make Changes From Within

1 / 2Jake Paul Invests in UFC, Reveals Plans To Make Changes From Within Jake Paul recently called out Dana White in a series of Tweets regarding his potential UFC ... Read more »

K-pop star Kang Daniel to make acting debut with Disney+ original 'Rookie Cops'

By Kim Boram SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — K-pop star Kang Daniel will make his acting debut in Disney+’s new coming-of-age romantic drama series “Rookie Cops.” The 16-episode series is ... Read more »

AP PHOTOS: Beast-like 'Carantoñas' return to Spanish town

The Associated PressMen dressed as wild animals or “Carantonas” walk towards the church during “Las Carantonas” festival in Acehuche, southeast Spain, Thursday, Jan. 20, 2022. With roots in pagan traditions ... Read more »

Spotify is looking for producers for podcast Harry and Meghan

Although Harry and Meghan signed a million-dollar deal with Spotify at the end of 2020 to make podcasts for the company, little has come of it so far. That is ... Read more »

'All Of Us Are Dead,' a Netflix zombie series set at school

By Shim Sun-ah SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — After the global success of “Kingdom,” Netflix is set to release another Korean-language zombie genre series Friday. “All Of Us Are Dead” ... Read more »

Ye: I intercepted Kim Kardashian's second sex tape

“I went to see the guy, got the laptop from him at the airport and flew straight back home. The laptop was in Kim’s possession the next morning and she ... Read more »

Grace Kelly's granddaughter Charlotte Casiraghi of Monaco rides horse on catwalk at Chanel show

Those in attendance to see the 11th-in-line to the throne of Monaco included Pharrell Williams and Margot Robbie. Read more »

[Feature] What do you know about Korean zombies?

“All of Us Are Dead” (Netflix)From their bloody makeup to bone-breaking motions, the zombies in Korean films and drama series have been satisfying viewers’ lust for the zombie apocalypse. But ... Read more »

Tonight on TV: Atlas, Girls who drive and Dirty Jobs

Because there is a lot to see on television every day, you can read the viewing tips for tonight here every morning. These are the recommendations for Wednesday 26 January. ... Read more »

Disney talks for remake Snow White with people with dwarfism after criticism

Peter Dinklage won an Emmy for his work on Game of Thrones.Image EPA Actor Peter Dinklage (52), who was born with a form of dwarfism, had spoken out in comedian ... Read more »

Kim Kardashian Responds to Ex Kanye West's Claims About a Second Sex Tape with Ray J

Kim Kardashian is setting the record straight about allegations of a second sex tape. On Tuesday, Hollywood Unlocked released a new video from when host Jason Lee sat down with ... Read more »

Alicia Witt reflects one month after parents were found dead in their home

One month after her parents were found dead in their Massachusetts home, actress Alicia Witt has opened up about her sudden loss and her parents' legacy. Witt, best known for ... Read more »

Nick Jonas and Priyanka Chopra 'Excited' to Be Parents, 'Wanted a Baby for Some Time': Source

Nick Jonas and Priyanka Chopra Jonas couldn't be more excited to begin their journey as parents. The couple welcomed their first baby, a daughter, via surrogate on Saturday, Jan. 15, ... Read more »

Disney takes criticism to heart and talks to people with dwarfism for remake Snow White

Dinklage, known for his role as Tyrion Lannister in the HBO series Game of Thrones, suffers from dwarfism himself and thinks the story is outdated. “I was a little surprised ... Read more »

Rihanna pledges $15 million to climate justice movement through her Clara Lionel foundation

Rihanna, who is from Barbados, said the large donation will go to 18 climate justice organisations carrying out work in seven Caribbean nations and the United States. Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic