A gay New York teacher was fired from a Catholic school after marrying his partner

Asia's Tech News Daily

A man putting a wedding ring on another man’s hand. Getty Images

  • A gay teacher was fired from a Catholic school in Queens, New York, after he got married in August.

  • Matthew LaBanca lost both his job as a teacher and as a music director at a nearby church.

  • The Diocese of Brooklyn confirmed LaBanca had been terminated and cited “church law.”

A music teacher at a school in the New York City borough of Queens was fired by the Catholic Church just six weeks after his August wedding.

The teacher, Matthew LaBanca, says – and the church appears to have confirmed – that his termination from St. Joseph Catholic Academy in the neighborhood of Astoria was a result not of poor work performance or misconduct but rather of having a same-sex marriage. LaBanca was fired as music director at the nearby Corpus Christi Church as well.

“I'm stripped of both of my jobs, all of my employment, my health insurance, and, most importantly, the community life that has meant so much to me, not because of my work performance – not in the slightest – but because I'm gay,” he said in a YouTube video recounting his experience.

LaBanca said in the video that his termination was sparked when someone reached out to the Diocese of Brooklyn with information about his wedding in what he called “an apparent act of righteousness.” Diocese officials spent six weeks deliberating LaBanca's employment status before deciding to fire him earlier this month, he said.

LaBanca told the local outlet WABC-TV that he was surprised by the decision because he was out as gay before his wedding.

“I thought now, in 2021, we were moving forward and that this was not something I had to be concerned about,” he told the outlet.

While the state of New York prohibits employers from penalizing employees based on their sexual orientation and marital status, the First Amendment's religious protections allowed for LaBanca's legal termination from the Catholic Church entities.

“But just because something is legal, doesn't make it right,” he said in the YouTube video.

The diocese did not reject LaBanca's account, telling Insider “church law is clear.”

“Matthew's contract has been terminated based on the expectation that all Catholic school and academy personnel, and ministers of the church, comply with church teachings as they share in the responsibility of ministering the faith to students,” a representative for the diocese said.

“In his case, it has been determined that he can no longer fulfill his obligations as a minister of the faith at either the school or the parish,” the statement added.

The statement highlighted a condition within teacher contracts that requires employees “to support and exemplify” Catholic doctrine with their public conduct.

LaBanca praised his former principal in the YouTube video, calling him his “fiercest advocate,” and placed the blame on Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio, who leads the Brooklyn Diocese.

He said he was offered a severance package that included a nearly 10-page gag order.

“Obviously I have not signed it, because I realized no price could be placed on my personal integrity,” LaBanca said.

He told WABC-TV he hadn't decided whether he'd pursue legal action against the diocese but emphasized that he missed his job and, most of all, his students.

LaBanca did not immediately respond to a request for comment from Insider.

Read the original article on Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Female police constable, 21, faces the sack after being convicted of stalking - just months after starting in the force

Emma Bewick, 21, of South Wales, convicted of stalking victim Gavin BurrowsShe was handed 10-week suspended sentence at Cwmbran Magistrates CourtBewick will now face accelerated misconduct hearing to decide if she gets fired Read more »

Viewers slam Sarah Beeny's New Life in the Country for being 'another show about how rich people spend their money' - and mock 'spoilt' family for putting busts of themselves in stately home on 220 acres

Property entrepreneur's second series of New Life in the Country sparked criticism after first episode of the second series for Channel 4 aired on TuesdayDuring the show, Beeny, her artist husband Graham Swift and their four boys Laurie, Charlie, Rafferty and Billy, are seen helping out with building workThe family hope to move into the five-bed, five bathroom stately home - which sits on 220 acres of Somerset farmland - within eight months Some viewers weren't impressed, one called the house a 'middle class monster' and another said it was just a show about 'how rich people spend their money'  Read more »

Englands Frauen gewinnen mit 20:0 – und lassen Zweifel am Quali-System aufkommen

© Tim Goode/keystone-sda.ch Keine Spannung, dafür viele Tore: Das Spiel zwischen England und Lettland endete 20:0. Am Dienstagabend feierte die Schweizer Frauen-Fussballnationalmannschaft in der WM-Quali einen Kantersieg. Die Nati setzte ... Read more »

Ex-hotel worker reveals how they get back at rude guests

A FORMER hotel worker has revealed how they get back at guests who are annoying them or have been rude to them. And if you find your key card doesn't ... Read more »

Schweizer Unihockey-Nati steht nach 6:2-Sieg im WM-Viertelfinal

Die Schweizer Unihockey-Frauen gewinnen das dritte und letzte Gruppenspiel an der WM in Schweden gegen Polen mit 6:2. Trotz eines harzigen Starts konnten sich die Schweizerinnen am Schluss absetzen. Widmer ... Read more »

Michelle Keegan braves sub-zero temperatures in a cropped jacket as she films Brassic series four

MICHELLE Keegan winced as she hopped out of a red van in a rainy and cold Manchester. The actress braved sub-zero temperatures in a cropped jacket while filming series four ... Read more »

When does Spotify Wrapped 2021 come out?

SPOTIFY users can access their personalized sound experience exclusively in the mobile app. Here is everything you need to know about the Spotify Wrapped 2021 release date. Wrapped is a ... Read more »

These are the world's most expensive cities to live in

© Provided by Al Jazeera New York City ranked sixth on the list of the world’s most expensive cities [File: Mary Altaffer/AP] Tel Aviv is the most expensive city in ... Read more »

Dozens, including many children, die in Nigeria boat disaster

© Provided by Al Jazeera An overloaded boat carrying dozens of passengers, mostly children aged eight to 15, has capsized on Bagwai River in northwest Nigeria’s Kano state, according to ... Read more »

The hypocrisy of Emmerson Mnangagwa

© Provided by Al Jazeera Mnangagwa should not be allowed to ‘greenwash’ his government’s damaging actions or blame everything that is still wrong with the country on EU and US ... Read more »

Projek HSR: PM bentang hasil pertemuan dengan Singapura Jumaat

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Wee Ka Siong berkata Ismail Sabri Yaakob dan Perdana Menteri Singapura Lee Hsien Loong, masing-masing terbuka meneliti semula pelaksanaan projek HSR. (Gambar Bernama) PETALING ... Read more »

Sex and the City reboot And Just Like That confirms Carrie and Big's relationship status

Sex and the City fans have been eagerly awaiting more details of the anticipated series reboot, And Just Like That, including if Carrie Bradshaw (Sarah Jessica Parker) and Big (Chris ... Read more »

Polaris' new Ranger XP Kinetic is an all-electric side-by-side with a lot of horsepower

Polaris has unveiled the Ranger XP Kinetic, an all-electric side-by-side and the first vehicle to emerge from the collaboration between the Minneapolis-based company and Zero Motorcycles. Polaris is hoping the ... Read more »

EU seeks to ease rules for Poland, Baltics in migration standoff with Belarus

© Reuters/Yves Herman FILE PHOTO: EU flags flutter in front of the European Commission headquarters in Brussels By Gabriela Baczynska BRUSSELS (Reuters) – The European Union executive on Wednesday will ... Read more »

UAE's Ahmed Seddiqi & Sons releases

© Motivate Publishing Mohammed Abdulmagied Seddiqi, chief commercial officer at Ahmed Seddiqi & Sons The UAE has leapfrogged from a fragile union of independent emirates back in 1971, to today ... Read more »

Khehla Sitole's performance at hearings 'depressing to citizens and police'

© Provided by 702 National Police Commissioner General Khehla Sitole took a lot of heat yesterday for statements before a commission hearings into July civil unrest. Independent Policing Union of ... Read more »

Some grants, food security programmes affected by July riots, Zulu tells SAHRC

© @SAHRCommission/Twitter Social Development Minister Lindiwe Zulu testifies virtually at the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) inquiry into the July riots on 1 December 2021. DURBAN – Social Development ... Read more »

After 40 years of AIDS, equality remains central to quelling a still-potent epidemic

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved To end AIDS by 2030, we must meet the challenge of overcoming fear, discrimination and stigma to ensure life-saving treatments and ... Read more »

It might not feel like it to some students, but university staff strikes are in their best interests

Since around 2018, staff strikes over poor conditions, cuts and pensions have repeatedly disrupted the academic year, with the largest seeing 74 universities strike over 14 days in 2020. This ... Read more »

Donald Trump ‘tested positive for Covid a few days before Joe Biden debate'

© AFP via Getty trump-biden-composite.jpg Donald Trump tested positive for Covid-19 three days before his first debate against Joe Biden, according to his former chief of staff. According to the ... Read more »

Case against NW father who murdered daughter (2) transferred to High Court

© SAPS Gavel on cuffs. CAPE TOWN – The case against a North West man charged with the kidnapping and murder of his two-year-old daughter will be transferred to the ... Read more »

Battle to save democracy, oust BJP: Mamata to intellectuals

© Provided by The Statesman Battle to save democracy, oust BJP: Mamata to intellectuals In an effort to galvanise opposition, chief minister Mamata Banerjee today interacted with eminent members of ... Read more »

India's NY consulate official tells woman ‘take your money & go' in viral video, disciplined

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: A video of an Indian officer in the Consulate General of India in New York, refusing a woman a visa and telling her ... Read more »

Kochi: 1 killed, 2 injured after car rams into metro pillar at Pathadipalam

A 22-year-old woman was killed and two others were left injured after a speeding car allegedly rammed a metro pillar at Pathadipalam on NH66 in Kochi. The incident took place ... Read more »

115 Kashmiri Pandit Families Left Valley for Jammu in Oct, But Not Due to Security Fears

© Provided by News18 115 Kashmiri Pandit Families Left Valley for Jammu in Oct, But Not Due to Security Fears According to the latest figures by the Ministry of Home ... Read more »

GFP allies with Congress for 2022 Goa Assembly polls, irked TMC calls it 'unholy alliance'

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Goa Forward Party (GFP) has allied with Congress for the upcoming Assembly polls next year, party president Vijay Sardesai announced on Wednesday (December ... Read more »

Ukraine's Zelensky calls for direct talks with Russia ‘to end war'

© Russian Defense Ministry Press Service, via AP (file photo) Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky on Wednesday called for direct negotiations with Russia to end an eight-year war with pro-Russian separatists ... Read more »

All Timed Research: Stardust Challenge tasks and rewards for Pokémon Go's Season of Heritage

© Provided by Dot Esports The Season of Heritage is now underway in Pokémon Go, meaning players are going to be working closely with Professor Willow and the various Team ... Read more »

Map shows Met Police stations sold off for £131 million in bid to save cash

The Met Police has raked in over £131m since the pandemic began by selling off police stations, MyLondon can reveal. The “fire sale” of locals stations has triggered concerns over ... Read more »

Priyanka Chopra opens up about marriage to Nick Jonas amid 'really tough' work schedules

© Provided by Cover Media Priyanka Chopra Priyanka Chopra has opened up about how she stays connected to her husband Nick Jonas amid their busy work schedules. In an interview ... Read more »

EU special envoy for Afghanistan to visit India next week

© Provided by Hindustan Times Taliban fighters stand guard near a military hospital in Kabul. (AFP/File) India and the European Union (EU) will have an opportunity to exchange notes and ... Read more »

Ariana Grande, Kelly Clarkson out-diva each other in karaoke showdown

The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon YT Ariana Grande and Kelly Clarkson just belted it out karaoke-style in the spirit of good, clean fun! On Tuesday, “The Tonight Show Starring ... Read more »

Ex-policeman charged with killing neighbors in Tarlac dies

© The Manila Times Jonel Nuezca PHOTO FROM CENTRAL LUZON POLICE Jonel Nuezca PHOTO FROM CENTRAL LUZON POLICE A former policeman who was imprisoned after gunning down his two neighbors ... Read more »

‘I got to live my dreams': Johanna Konta announces retirement from tennis aged 30

© Reuters Johanna Konta has called time her tennis career – Reuters Johanna Konta has announced her retirement from tennis at the age of 30, saying she lived out her ... Read more »

Section 144 extended in UP's Gautam Budh Nagar till December 31

Section 144 has been extended in Gautam Budh Nagar till December 31 Ahead of Christmas and New Year celebrations, the Police Commissionerate of Uttar Pradesh’s Gautam Buddh Nagar imposed Section ... Read more »

DWP announces new service as pensioners warned of Post Office card accounts closures

Hundreds of thousands of Britons use Post Office Card Accounts, but these are soon set to close. However, users will now have more time to change their plans following the ... Read more »

News updates from HT: Alert issued in Odisha, Andhra for cyclone Jawad formation and all the latest news

© Provided by Hindustan Times Cyclone Jawad may reach the coasts of Andhra Pradesh and Odisha on the morning of December 4, (AFP Photo/Representative use) (HT_PRINT) Here are today’s top news, ... Read more »

Lumo: one month on, how is the new London-Edinburgh train doing?

By the time I found my seat, my neighbour was halfway through a substantial meal of the kind that is fine when in a fast food restaurant but whose aroma ... Read more »

‘Clear of Lukaku' – Many Charlton fans discuss one player's return in Aston Villa win

© Provided by Football League World League One – Charlton Athletic v Lincoln City Charlton Athletic confirmed their place in the next round of the Papa John’s Trophy with a ... Read more »

Commuters say more people ARE wearing face coverings on Tube

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Commuters today reported a noticeable rise in the proportion of London Underground passengers wearing face masks just over 24 hours after they were ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic