A controversial home-ownership model is gaining steam again in L.A. — with a twist

A new housing model that landed in Los Angeles several years ago made home ownership more affordable in pricey neighborhoods, a welcome option in a housing-starved region.

It also had a major flaw, according to critics: Investors often displaced tenants in cheaper rentals to renovate their units and resell them.

Now, an L.A. developer has a new approach to the so-called tenancy-in-common, or TIC, model, in which residents share ownership of the property. Instead of converting old, rent-controlled buildings into TIC properties, the developer is replacing single-family homes with new townhomes.

That adds less costly housing stock to the area with fewer chances of displacement since most single-family houses are owner-occupied.

“I thought this wasn’t something I could afford,” said Ricky Howard, a 34-year old buying his first home, a three-bedroom townhouse in Arlington Heights with stainless steel appliances, quartz countertops and central air conditioning.

“I was … questioning why was it priced at $749,000,” he said, “and it’s new construction.”

At TIC developments, rather than own an individual unit on a lot like a condominium, residents own a share of the overall lot and have exclusive rights to live in their unit, with homeowners association dues covering the property’s upkeep. They are similar to New York City co-ops and came to L.A. from San Francisco, where they had been budding for decades.

B&A Group LLC, the builder of the four-unit project in Arlington Heights, has several more on the way, and at least one other developer is planning similar projects. Some real estate experts said the model could help theregion’s gaping affordable-housing problem, particularly after a new state law opened more areas to similar development.

a controversial home-ownership model is gaining steam again in l.a. —  with a twist
Aldo Cali, left, and Brisa Acosta are the brother-and sister team behind a number of new tenancy-in-common projects in Los Angeles that tear down single-family homes and build townhome-like developments.(Myung J. Chun / Los Angeles Times)

B&A has finished three projects so far; the others are in West Adams and Westlake.

In Arlington Heights, the three-bedroom homes went up for sale between $749,000 and $849,000 — at least $159,000 less than the typical three bedroom in the central Los Angeles neighborhood, and cheaper than most newly built condos and townhomes in the city, according to a Times analysis of Zillow data and listings.

Aldo Cali, who runs B&A with his sister Brisa Acosta, said they focus on replacing single-family homes with new construction because they don’t want to displace anyone. And it’s hard to make projects work financially when demolishing multi-unit structures to build just a few new units.

The new TICs from B&A preceded Senate Bill 9, the state law that allows up to four units on most lots formerly zoned for one single-family house. Some single-family houses in the city already saton parcels zoned for more units, often times a maximum of four, enabling projects such as B&A’s.

“Being able to take one home and turn it now into four homes that could give someone the opportunity to own a home in Los Angeles … we like that whole idea,” Acosta said.

In the debate over the new construction enabled by SB 9, some opponents raised concerns developers would demolish relatively affordable single-family homes and replace them with expensive rentals.

Cali and Acosta said the old homes they buy often need significant work that would put them out of reach for many first-time buyers. Most of the new TIC townhomes, on the other hand, have sold to first-time buyers, according to the real estate agent handling the deals.

Except for one single family house built as part of a three-unit TIC development in West Adams, B&A’s new townhome units are all three bedrooms with roughly 1,500 square feet and a rooftop deck or a small yard.

All 10 of those townhomes were first listed between 9% and 26% less than the typical price for a three bedroom in those neighborhoods, or the equivalent of $81,000 to $259,000 cheaper.

New homes at a discount

Howard, who is under contract for a unit at the TIC project in Arlington Heights, said he had grown tired of paying $3,000 a month in rent for a one-bedroom apartment near work and wanted to start building equity.

The owner of a streetwear store in downtown L.A., he said the only homes he could afford in his desired neighborhoods were fixer-uppers, or one-bedroom and studio condos. It took six months of searching and roughly three lost offers before he came across B&A’s townhomes.

One home he had bid on had 20 competing offers, he said. By comparison, buying a newer, nicer TIC has been a breeze.

“I think it’s smart for when I get older,” Howard said, of owning an asset rather than spending money on rent. “I can have something that I own.”

How his opportunity came to be is a story of zoning and economics.

In recent years, developers including B&A have demolished single-family houses that sat on L.A. lots already zoned for two to four units.

According to interviews with developers and a Times analysis of city records, the hundreds of new two- to four-unit projects that developers built were primarily for lease, with just a smattering of for-sale condos and a type of for-sale housing known as small lots — homes that look like townhomes, but are actually detached single-family houses.

Some of the new rental units were pricey, high-end units, while others were cheap enough to qualify as Section 8 housing.

Most projects are rentals because it takes too long to get city approvals to sell units individually as condos or small lots, developers said.

By 2019, though, investors had started to convert old rental housing into TIC units, which unlike small lots and condo conversions required no special city approvals and could be done quickly — a major plus for them since time is money.

L.A. real estate agent Skyler Hynes, who was working with B&A at the time to lease rentals, said he and the developer eventually figured they could use that new model to sell off individual townhomes and potentially make more money than selling an entire property to a landlord.

Cali said they bought all houses on the open market and make a point of asking the listing agents whether anyone would be displaced with the sale, something he said the agents said wouldn’t happen.

“That’s not what we are about,” he said.

According to county records and an interview with one previous owner, at least five of the seven houses B&A bought had been owner-occupied. One house had been rented before the sale, according to the tenant, who said the landlord let him move into another rental she owned for the same rental price.

Multiple industry insiders believe B&A was the first developer to offer newly built TICs in the L.A. market, with others since taking up model.

Isaac Davidi, a prominent developer of two- and four-unit rentals in Los Angeles, said he has about 40 new TIC buildings planned, with the first one expected to be finished in West Adams in about three months. “It’s more profitable,” he said.

Future B&A projects are plannedin West Adams, Westlake, Mid City and North Hollywood.

All of the townhomes B&A has finished so farwere listed and sold, or are still available, in the $700,000s and $800,000s. Hynes said the list price is roughly a 10% to 20% discount to what a similar newly built condo or small lot would cost in that location.

Several B&A homes actually sold under the original list price, including the one Howard is buying.

B&A can still make a profit selling the homes at a lower price: The developer saves time because special city approvals aren’t necessary in TIC cases, Hynes said.

The particular features of TICs — the shared ownership structure, for example, and the lack of fixed-rate financing options for them — also mean they aren’t swamped with buyer-interest the way most California homes are these days.

Adding supply

If newly built TICs prove reasonably profitable for developers, and the model takes off, it could have a “substantial impact” on improving housing affordability, UCLA professor Paavo Monkkonen said.

As developers build more TICs, more for-sale units will become available — the supply will grow — potentially easing the bidding wars between buyers that characterize today’s market.

SB 9 has also opened up many more lots to two- and four-unit development, adding opportunities for others to try the single-family-home-to-TIC pathway.

Larry Gross, executive director for the tenant rights group Coalition for Economic Survival, said the way B&A is developing TICs has the potential for less tenant displacement compared with the more common rental conversions.

But if the model catches on, he said, he worries other developers will pressure low-income homeowners to sell en-masse, then build and sell homes for far more than B&A prices. A familiar cycle would then begin, he said, with high-earners moving in and driving home prices up further.

“This could be devastating,” he said.

Even the discounts B&A’s projects now offer are a concern for Steven Meeks, president of the neighborhood council for West Adams. The area has seen prices skyrocket in recent years as higher income, often white households, move into the mostly working-class Latino and Black neighborhood.

“Cheaper for who?” he said of the new townhomes. “What person in this neighborhood is going to afford that?”

Cali said he worries “about everybody’s concerns,” but he feels his projects are helping affordability, including in West Adams where he sold two, three bedroom townhomes for $780,000 and $795,000, far less than the typical three bedroom now valued at over $1 million.

“It’s bringing back a little piece of the middle-class, figuring out how to even get into something,” he said.

UCLA’s Monkkonen said it’s also important to consider what could’ve happened absent B&A’s purchase of the old houses: It’s common for investors to purchase old, rundown homes and renovate them to much higher values — something that doesn’t add any additional units and happens frequently in West Adams and across the city.

B&A’s projects, meanwhile, are adding housing that is cheaper than many options in the surrounding area, a quicker way to expand affordability than waiting for more supply to trickle down, Monkkonen said.

All but one of the 10 new townhomes B&A has built can be considered less expensive than the old houses they replaced, records show.

According to public records, B&A paid $850,000 in 2019 for the single-family house in Arlington Heights it demolished to build four townhomes.

Those four new townhomes went on the market between $749,000 and $849,000, meaning all four were available for less than B&A paid for the original house two years prior. Some buyers are in escrow below those list prices, an even steeper discount.

It’s a more complicated case with the developer’s other projects. Those townhomes sold for more than what B&A paid in 2019 for the houses they replaced. But as any observer of the nation’s housing market knows: real estate appreciates.

A home’s price doesn’t rise in exact tandem with the market. But if B&A never demolished the old houses and their value climbed exactly as estimated by Zillow for the typical house, all but one of B&A’s six remaining townhomes sold for less than the theoretical value of the houses they replaced.

Times staff writers Ben Poston and Thomas Suh Lauder contributed to this report.

VIDEO | 05:45

LA Times Today: A controversial home-ownership model is gaining steam again in L.A. — with a twist

a controversial home-ownership model is gaining steam again in l.a. —  with a twist

Watch L.A. Times Today at 7 p.m. on Spectrum News 1 on Channel 1 or live stream on the Spectrum News App. Palos Verdes Peninsula and Orange County viewers can watch on Cox Systems on channel 99.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Sarah Huckabee Sanders Vows A 'Kid' In The Womb Will Be As Safe As Those In Classrooms

© Provided by HuffPost (Photo: Chip Somodevilla via Getty Images) (Photo: Chip Somodevilla via Getty Images) Arkansas gubernatorial candidate Sarah Huckabee Sanders vowed in a recent speech that she would “make ... Read more »

Coi Leray Returns to Y2K Style In Boxy Blazer, Bralette & Denim Thigh-High Boots

© Michael Buckner for Variety Coi Leray The BET Awards have returned to the Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles on Sunday. And the red carpet is already heating up. Coi ... Read more »

Roborock’s New Self-Emptying Q-Series Gives You Flagship Features Without the Flagship Price

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SPY.com may receive an affiliate commission. The best self-emptying robot vacuums can now cost as ... Read more »

The Perfect Summer Dress Exists, and We May Have Found It

© Provided by The Daily Beast Photo Illustration by Thomas Levinson/The Daily Beast/Getty You’re standing in the kitchen at a cramped apartment party, loudly catching up with an acquaintance whose ... Read more »

Ailing oceans in the spotlight at major UN meet

© FRED TANNEAU Oceans generate 50 percent of the oxygen we breathe A long-delayed UN conference on how to restore the faltering health of global oceans kicks off in Lisbon ... Read more »

7 Things You Should Not Include in Your Will

1/8 SLIDES © Dmytro Zinkevych / Shutterstock.com 7 Things You Should Not Include in Your Will While the number of older Americans with wills has been dropping in recent years, ... Read more »

Mindy Kaling on the pressures of TikTok for young comedians, her approach to 'Legally Blonde 3'

WEST HOLLYWOOD, Calif. — For many writers, the prospect of penning a sequel to one of the most beloved films of all time, on top of managing multiple writers’ rooms, ... Read more »

McKinney Officials Investigate Fire That Burned 7 Under-Construction Homes

NBC 5 News The cause of a fire that tore through a McKinney neighborhood remains under investigation Sunday. According to the McKinney Fire Department, flames took out seven homes that ... Read more »

Firefighters among 11 injured in Brooklyn bike shop fire

SUNSET PARK, Brooklyn (WABC) — Eleven people were hurt in a fire inside a bike shop in Brooklyn. Two firefighters and nine others were injured when the fire broke out ... Read more »

UK bill to override N.Ireland Brexit deal back in parliament

© Paul Faith Brussels threatened legal action after London earlier this month introduced the Northern Ireland Protocol Bill to unilaterally change trading terms for the British province A UK government ... Read more »

Reporter's Notebook: How has inflation affected the defense budget?

© Provided by Washington Examiner Washington Examiner Defense Reporter Mike Brest joins Jim Antle to discuss how inflation has affected the defense budget.   Washington Examiner Videos Tags: National Security, ... Read more »

KPRC 2′s Randy McIlvoy and Ari Alexander break down what they expect from the Houston Rockets on the eve of the NBA draft

With the NBA draft just one day away, KPRC 2 sports director Randy McIlvoy and sports anchor/reporter Ari Alexander sit down to share their thoughts on what the Houston Rockets ... Read more »

Stars Use BET Awards Stage to Criticize Roe V. Wade Ruling

Performers include Lil Wayne, Chance the Rapper, Ella Mai, Roddy Ricch, Lizzo and Kirk Franklin Read more »

Report: Dodgers interested in trading for Frankie Montas, Luis Castillo

© Ken Blaze-USA TODAY Sports Jun 11, 2022; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Oakland Athletics starting pitcher Frankie Montas (47) throws a pitch during the first inning against the Cleveland Guardians at ... Read more »

By leaking 1-year suspension target for Deshaun Watson, NFL is already applying pressure to case's arbitrator

HOUSTON — Late last week, when details of the NFL’s suspension stance in the Deshaun Watson investigation began to privately circulate between parties involved in the case, a source in ... Read more »

Young Fan Who Cried After Votto’s Ejection Witnesses Another Untimely Ejection

© Provided by Sports Illustrated Don’t worry, this story has a happy ending. View the original article to see embedded media. Sunday’s brawl between the Mariners and Angels was one ... Read more »

High School Sports Awards: National show to highlight elite student-athlete achievement

The USA TODAY High School Sports Awards is the nation’s largest high school sports recognition program, celebrating the best in high school sports in cities and states nationwide. Accolades will ... Read more »

7-year-old girl drowns in backyard pool in New Jersey

TEANECK, New Jersey (WABC) — A 7-year-old drowned at a backyard pool in New Jersey. Police arrived at the house on Westervelt Place in Teaneck just after 6 p.m. Sunday ... Read more »

Alice Springs homelessness increasing, accommodation provider reports tripling in requests for help

Under the cold Red Centre skies, David Pearsall is woken by mice gnawing at his frost-covered tent set up behind Telegraph Station. Key points: The number of people sleeping rough ... Read more »

Anderson Cooper on witnessing Tony Bennett's final act

When Tony Bennett hears the opening notes of a familiar song, he still knows what to do. Let someone start believing in you… Steady on his feet, he takes his ... Read more »

Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden, other officials speaking out ahead of LIV event near Portland

Several Oregon officials are speaking out on Sunday ahead of the first LIV Golf event scheduled for the state later this week. The LIV Golf Invitational Series will host its ... Read more »

Taraji P Henson Glitters in Double Slit Dress With Steel Neck Chain Strap & Disco Heels on BET Awards 2022 Red Carpet

© Michael Buckner for Variety BET Awards 2022 – Arrivals Taraji P Henson arrived on the red carpet for the BET Awards on Sunday in Los Angeles in sparkling style. ... Read more »

Man Who Lost Both Legs After Hit-and-Run on Michigan Avenue Heads Home

Bryce Summary, who was injured when a driver struck him May 21, said he doesn't blame Chicago for what happened to him Read more »

Suspect shot by officer in north Houston, HPD says

HPD said the incident happened along the North Freeway near Crosstimbers. Read more »

4 killed when stands collapse during Colombian bullfight

Videos taken during the bullfight show a three-story section of the stands collapsing as people screamed. Read more »

3 dead, 2 injured in Amtrak collision: Officials

Three people are dead and two others seriously injured after an Amtrak train collided with a car in Brentwood, California, on Sunday, the East Contra Costa Fire Department told ABC ... Read more »

Schools Are Spending Billions on High-Tech Defense for Mass Shootings

© Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools Students at Mallard Creek High School in Charlotte, N.C., using Evolv scanners. Correction: June 26, 2022 This article has been revised to reflect the following correction: An ... Read more »

Ecuador warns protests could force halt to oil production

© MARTIN BERNETTI Roads blocked during the ongoing protests in Ecuador have hindered oil production and could force a halt to output, the government says Ecuador’s energy ministry warned Sunday ... Read more »

Houston Man Gets Life In Prison After Fatally Shooting 3 Men

NBC 5 News A Houston man has been sentenced to life in prison for shooting four men, including three who were killed, in the aftermath of a drug deal gone ... Read more »

The Best 85-Inch TVs You Can Buy in 2022 — Compare Top Models From Samsung, LG & Sony

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SPY.com may receive an affiliate commission. TVs are available in pretty much any size you ... Read more »

Cory Burke lifts Philadelphia over New York City FC

Cory Burke scored a dramatic tiebreaking goal in the 96th minute as the host Philadelphia Union survived blowing a late lead and moved into first place in the Eastern Conference ... Read more »

Foot bruise may land Braves' Ronald Acuna Jr. back on IL

© Brett Davis-USA TODAY Sports Jun 25, 2022; Atlanta, Georgia, USA; Atlanta Braves right fielder Ronald Acuna Jr. (13) reacts during the fifth inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers at ... Read more »

Dolph Lundgren Takes Fiancée Emma Krokdal to Her First Premiere, Hopes to Marry 'Next Year'

© Provided by People VALERIE MACON/AFP via Getty Dolph Lundgren is making his family movie genre debut with the whole brood. The Rocky IV star, 64, spoke to PEOPLE as ... Read more »

Report: LSU Baseball Hires Twins Pitching Coach Wes Johnson

© Provided by Sports Illustrated He’ll leave the organization after four years to return to the SEC. View the original article to see embedded media. In a rare midseason move, ... Read more »

Jack Harlow Shows Support for Friend Lil Nas X at 2022 BET Awards

Now this is a first class friendship. Jack Harlow, 24, has arrived at the 2022 BET Awards sporting a statement-making shirt in support of his “Industry Baby” collaborator Lil Nas ... Read more »

The most famous company founded the year you were born

1/57 SLIDES © Courtesy AHC See the most famous firm founded in your birth year Making a business work over the long term is a major challenge. Research shows the ... Read more »

Burke gives first-place Union 2-1 victory over NYCFC

CHESTER, Pa. (AP) — Cory Burke’s goal lifted the Philadelphia Union to a 2-1 victory over New York City FC on Sunday. Burke’s game-winner came in the eighth minute of ... Read more »

Patrick Mahomes and Wife Brittany Announce Sex of Baby No. 2 With Splashy Reveal

Less than two years after welcoming their daughter Sterling, Patrick and Brittany Mahomes announced that their firstborn is getting a baby brother Read more »

3 dead after Amtrak train hits car near Brentwood

© JOSE CARLOS FAJARDO/Bay Area News Group/TNS UNINCORPORATED BRENTWOOD, CALIFORNIA – JUNE 26: Contra Costa Sheriff deputies investigate the scene after an Amtrak train collided with a vehicle in unincorporated ... Read more »

Warren Sapp heard Colin Kaepernick's Raiders workout was a 'disaster'

© Rick Osentoski-USA TODAY Sports Colin Kaepernick passes during halftime at the Michigan Spring game at Michigan Stadium. Colin Kaepernick had his first formal visit with an NFL team in ... Read more »