A case of sour grapes? Chateau owner accused of conflict of interest by those who didn't make grade

A case of sour grapes? Chateau owner accused of conflict of interest by those who didn't make grade

Hubert de Boüard, 65, co-owner of the world-renowned Château Angélus and an iconic figure in the vineyards of Bordeaux, denied on Monday that he had played a role in the development of the 2012 classification of the Grands Crus of Saint-Emilion, where he is suspected by three failed châteaux of acting in his own interest.

This 65-year-old wine consultant and Philippe Castéja, 72, a major merchant and owner of Château Trotte Vieille, have until Tuesday to answer the accusation of an “unlawful acquisition of an interest” before the criminal court of Bordeaux for their alleged involvement in the classification pertaining to commercial and financial benefits.

In 2012, they were members of the INAO (National Institute of origin and quality – Institut national de l’origine et de la qualité) wine committee, which falls under the Ministry of Agriculture. This body validated the rules of the classification and their results, drawn up by a commission whose members it had appointed.

More active than Castéja according to the investigation, de Boüard was also a member of the Organisme de défense et de gestion (ODG) des vins de Saint-Emilion, which participated in the development of the specifications for classification with the INAO.

“In no case did I participate,” said de Boüard at the hearing, while the president of the court reported to him “continuous comings and goings” of e-mails between the ODG and the INAO.

“I didn’t think for a second that answering it could be something reprehensible,” he said. “On the contrary, after the trauma of the cancellation (by the courts) of the 2006 classification, it was necessary to secure the new classification as much as possible.”

“As part of the INAO, I respected the rule from beginning to end,” the defendant added. For example, “I abstained from voting on the list of members of the classification committee”.

In 2012, the classification promoted its Château Angélus to premier grand cru classé “A” the highest rating in St Emilion, and maintained in “B” class the Trotte Vieille domaine of Castéja. Eight other properties for which de Boüard played a role (consultant or supervisor) were also given grand cru status.

The accusations came to light in summer 2019 when three chateaux cried foul play when they were either demoted or removed from the classification.

According to his lawyer Antoine Vey, de Boüard “suffers the vindictiveness of three unfortunate candidates” with charges “incomprehensible” and “poorly substantiated”: “This criminal action aims to harm him,” he added.

The two defendants face up to 5 years in prison and a fine of 500,000 euros.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


The airports battling to be the world's biggest super-hub

T3, Dubai Airport Last week I checked in for a flight, dropped off a hold bag, cleared immigration, entered the lounge and boarded the aircraft – just by using my ... Read more »

Real-life “Squid Game” canceled over COVID concerns, refunds issued

Poster for “Saint Game” (St. John’s Hotel’s Instagram)A hotel in Gangwon Province that organized an event based on Netflix’s megahit “Squid Game,” on Friday started issuing refunds to more than ... Read more »

Two Moscow restaurants receive two Michelin stars, seven more awarded one star

Moscow became the first city in the CIS space to receive Michelin stars Read more »

The Tragedy of Macbeth, Almeida, review: Saoirse Ronan makes a spellbinding British stage debut

James McArdle and Saoirse Ronan in The Tragedy of Macbeth, at the Almeida – Marc Brenner One of the most admired actresses of her generation, Saoirse Ronan is making her ... Read more »

The Tragedy of Macbeth review – Yaël Farber's blood-curdling terror

The psychological terror is slow to rear and does not always lie in the usual places in Yaël Farber’s take on Shakespeare’s tragedy of power, guilt and vaulting ambition. When ... Read more »

Rapid tests to replace PCRs for vaccinated travellers at half-term

(Alamy Stock Photo) Fully vaccinated holidaymakers returning from non red list countries can take a rapid test instead of a more expensive PCR from October 24. The latest rule change ... Read more »

Travellers to England able to take lateral flow Covid tests from 24 October

Photograph: Steve Parsons/PA Fully vaccinated international passengers arriving in England from countries not on the red list can take a cheaper and quicker lateral flow test from 24 October instead ... Read more »

America's most Instagrammed art museum revealed

Some museums are renowned for their artwork. Others, it seems, become famous as a backdrop for a very contemporary kind of art: the Instagram post. Now, thanks to hashtags used ... Read more »

You want my two TV recommendations? Succession and this superb Scottish drama

Mark Bonnar in Guilt – BBC/Robert Pereira Hind Writing about television means being asked, by friends and colleagues and strangers at parties, for recommendations of what to watch. And I’m ... Read more »

Banksy sets auction record with £18.5m sale of shredded painting

Photograph: Facundo Arrizabalaga/EPA A partially shredded Banksy painting has sold for more than £18.5m at auction, a record for the street artist. Love is in the Bin fetched £18,582,000 at ... Read more »

Banksy's shredded artwork sells for £18.6m in record for artist

Banksy – Sotheby’s Auction House/AP A partially shredded Banksy painting has sold for £18,582,000 at auction. His artwork Love Is In The Bin was sold in London by auction house ... Read more »

'Love is in the Bin': Shredded Banksy artwork sells for nearly €22 million at auction

A self-shredded work by British street artist Banksy has sold at auction for a record amount. “Love is in the Bin” was offered on sale by Sotheby’s in London, with ... Read more »

Two Moscow restaurants awarded two Michelin stars

MOSCOW, October 14. /TASS/. Two restaurants in Moscow received two Michelin stars at the ceremony held on Thursday. Artest Chef's Table and Twins Garden were awarded two stars. Read more »

British Airways recruits cabin crew after cutting thousands of jobs in 2020

British Airways has announced it is recruiting cabin crew, after thousands lost their jobs at the airline last year (Steve Parsons/PA) (PA Wire) British Airways has announced it is recruiting ... Read more »

Turn back time: How the Swiss watch industry is embracing second-hand sales

To some, a realm for only elite, well-cuffed buyers and private jet-riding debonairs, the Swiss watch industry is changing with the times and embracing a more thrifty, sustainable side: Second-hand ... Read more »

Jessie J Flashes Her Super Strong Abs In A New No-Makeup Instagram Story Selfie

Jessie J, 33, just revealed her six-pack abs in a brand new, no-makeup selfie on her Instagram Story. She rocks a brown crop top under a sheer shirt, and her ... Read more »

Coastal Croatia: How to spend a week in Split and Hvar

Croatian island of Hvar (Hvar Tourism ) Croatia's coastal cities have become a firm favourite with sun-seeking Brits looking to explore on and offshore. Split, the largest of them all, ... Read more »

Five of the best painting holidays for all abilities

Newlyn School of Art – Newlyn School of Art While other global leaders are sweating it out preparing for what is arguably the most important world summit for a generation, ... Read more »

EAEU countries intend to intensify efforts to combat climate change — statement

The EAEU member countries supported the convergence of approaches to observing and the verification of greenhouse gases emissions and absorption Read more »

US Embassy does not confirm rough treatment of Whelan in Russian penal colony

On December 28, 2018, Paul Whelan was detained by the Russian Federal Security Service (FSB) in a room at the Metropol Hotel in Moscow while on an alleged spy mission Read more »

Batch of Russian Sputnik V vaccine delivered to Iran, news agency says

In Iran, a free of charge and voluntary vaccination against coronavirus with the Russian Sputnik V began on February 9 Read more »

The best ski holiday deals to book now

skiing deals – Getty Snow has begun to fall in the mountains of Europe and, with every flake, the optimism for the upcoming ski season continues to grow. Ski lifts ... Read more »

Banksy shredded artwork ‘Love is in the Bin' tipped to fetch £6m at Sotheby's auction

Banksy’s Love Is In The Bin, which self-shredded immediately after it was sold at auction is up for sale again (PA Wire) A work by Banksy that sensationally self-shredded just ... Read more »

Punk take on Queen and Joker at new Mark Sloper art show

(Mark Sloper) A portrait of the Queen will be hanging side by side with The Joker in a new show by punk-inspired artist Mark Sloper. The painter from West London ... Read more »

Russian actress addresses Women's Forum participants from space

"I am happy to greet you from space. And I can tell you for sure: we, the women, can accomplish anything," Yulia Peresild said Read more »

White Noise, review: what happens when a black man pays a white man to enslave him?

Ken Nwosu and James Corrigan in White Noise, at the Bridge Theatre – Johan Persson In White Noise, her most naturalistic work to date, Pulitzer prize-winning Suzan-Lori Parks presents a ... Read more »

Travel to the Philippines: Latest Covid rules and practical guidance

girl snorkelling in blue waters near boat – John Seaton Callahan /Moment RF The Philippines has finally been removed from the red list, meaning that arrivals are no longer subject ... Read more »

The forgotten British rail routes we would love to return

Gorse bushes on Dartmoor with Meldon Viaduct in the distance – Zoblinski/Getty Exploring Dartmoor will become that much easier from next month. The Dartmoor Line between Okehampton and Exeter will ... Read more »

A Belgium school has given the 'red light' to children reenacting Netflix's Squid Game

Despite being deemed unsuitable for viewers under 18, the Korean drama Squid Game has led to some schoolchildren trying to recreate the show’s violent survival games. Since its release on ... Read more »

10 Northern Lights cruises to book now

Viking Sky In Search of the Northern Lights – ALASTAIR MILLER The Northern Lights – or Aurora Borealis as they are officially known – have lit up winter skies over ... Read more »

Heidi Klum and Seal's model daughter Leni makes rare red carpet appearance with dad

Leni Klum made a rare red carpet appearance with her father, Seal last night. (Getty Images) Leni Klum, the model daughter of Heidi Klum and Seal has made a rare ... Read more »

Slow travel, high-tech hotels and bucket-list adventures: this is what travel in 2022 will look like

(Unsplash) With Reuters reporting a 700 per cent increase in searches for flights to America on BA’s website after the US announced its easing of travel restrictions from next month, ... Read more »

‘Beautiful buildings wherever you look': Germany's best towns and villages, by readers

Photograph: John MacDougall/AFP/Getty Images Winning tip: A ‘film set’ close to the Polish border We arrived in Görlitz, Germany’s most easterly town, to find it packed with peasants swilling beer ... Read more »

The Beauty Queen of Leenane at Lyric Hammersmith review: A twisted mother and daughter tale

Mag (Ingrid Craigie) and Maureen (Orla Fitzgerald) (Helen Maybanks) So many of Martin McDonagh’s hallmarks are present and correct in his first play The Beauty Queen of Leenane, first performed ... Read more »

Yamal equips socially important buildings with sensors to monitor permafrost conditions

Additionally, scientists at the laboratory have designed cement, which can survive without deformation frosts of up to minus 50 degrees Celsius Read more »

Nornickel plans to tidy up 2 million m2 in Norilsk Industrial District within 2021

According to the company’s Deputy Director of Federal and Regional Programs Department Igor Larichev, the work continues under the company’s 10-year program to clean the city Read more »

Inside the space camp where billionaires get a taste of zero gravity with their oysters and champagne

Participants in Orbite‘s astronaut training After performing press-ups on Mars and making giant leaps across the moon, we step up into the weightlessness of space. There I float for a ... Read more »

Russia's daily COVID-19 incidence hits all-time high of over 31,290 cases

Russia’s COVID-19 death toll reached the all-time high number of 986 since the start of the pandemic Read more »

Mexico hopes for early approval of Russian Sputnik V jab by WHO, says top diplomat

Since the end of 2020, almost 48.9 mln Mexicans have been fully vaccinated against COVID-19, while another 18 mln have received the first component of the jab Read more »

The British Brand Meghan Markle Buys Her Tights From

There are few things that terrify me, fashion-wise, quite as much as the thought of wearing nude tights. I've avoided them for as long as I can remember because they ... Read more »