‘A bit of a mystery': why hospital admissions for Covid in England are going down

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: David Levene/The Guardian

In early September, outbreak modelling for the government’s Sage advisers showed Covid hospitalisations had the potential to soar. If people rushed back to work and resumed all the socialising they had put on hold, the number of daily admissions in England could peak at 7,000 within six weeks. It was, in effect, a worst-case scenario, barring a dramatic waning of immunity or a troublesome new variant.

The optimistic scenario looked very different. Assuming a more gradual return to normality, the modelling had daily Covid hospitalisations rising slowly and slightly, topping out at nearly 2,000, before falling again in November. Now, even that looks overly gloomy. Over the past fortnight, hospitalisations have fallen in England, even as schools and offices reopened.

Mismatches between the modelling and the true course of the epidemic have caused confusion throughout the Covid crisis. The models are not predictions of what will happen. They are what the computers churn out when presented with a “what if?”. In this case, what if R (the reproduction number of the epidemic) reaches 1.1? And what if – as Jonathan Van-Tam, the deputy chief medical officer for England, would say – people “rip the pants off it” and push R to 1.5? That would mean, on average, every two people infected go on to infect three more.

© Photograph: David Levene/The Guardian People in a pub . Some experts point out that the UK has not rushed back to ‘life-before-Covid’.

Sage expected hospitalisations in England to peak somewhere near the lower range, namely 2,000 a day, but no sooner was the modelling complete than hospitalisations began to fall. The decline was unexpected. What it suggests is that – for now – the effect of unlocking on fuelling the epidemic is more than offset by the combination of people’s behaviour and immunity, whether from vaccination or infection.

“Those are two very powerful forces. Each by itself is perfectly capable of making the number of cases or hospitalisations go up or down, and they are basically fighting each other right now,” said Mark Woolhouse, professor of infectious disease epidemiology at Edinburgh University.

On Friday, the Office for National Statistics reported a fall in infection rates in England for the second week running, with one in 90 now estimated to test positive for Covid. Elsewhere in the UK, rates remain stable but high.

According to Prof Graham Medley, chair of the Sage modelling subgroup, Spi-M, while infections and admissions have drifted down in the past couple of weeks, little has changed over the larger timeframe of the past 10 weeks. “This is unexpected,” he said. “There must be a balance between the increasing immunity from infection and vaccination, and the amount of contact, but how they exactly balance to keep R roughly at 1 is a bit of a mystery.”

It may be that vaccines are more effective at preventing transmission than studies – often based on symptomatic patients – suggest. If that is the case, Woolhouse said, immunity may be playing a larger role in suppressing the epidemic than thought. After a sharp rise in Scotland, cases appear to be falling back down, without any obvious change in behaviour, he added. “It’s a watershed moment. This is the first time in the history of the UK’s epidemic that we’ve had a sustained decline in cases in the absence of a lockdown or not far short of it,” he said. “We’ve never seen that before, so clearly something is fundamentally different, and the fundamental difference for me is the buildup of herd immunity.”

Related: ‘Things are grim here’: doctor tells of dire situation in north-west England ICU

That would be excellent news, particularly if the rest of the UK follows suit. On Friday, the R number for England was revised to 0.8 to 1, with the number of new infections estimated to be shrinking at 1% to 3% a day. The difficulty is that, with a lot of virus still around, a manageable situation could become challenging very fast. “If there is an uptick then we need to react to that quickly. If this does go wrong, the NHS will be in trouble very quickly,” Woolhouse warned.

As Medley pointed out, the country has not rushed back to “life-before-Covid”. What happens next is still as murky as ever. “We are still a long way from normal levels of contact, so there is still the possibility of an increase in transmission and hospitalisations, but the past couple of months gives a lot of hope,” he said.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Love Story Box Office Collection: Naga Chaitanya and Sai Pallavi starrer continues its phenomenal run

© Provided by Pinkvilla Love Story, directed by Sekhar Kammula, starring Naga Chaitanya, Sai Pallavi in lead roles has taken the box office by storm. The film which was released ... Read more »

Skye by SUP: The ultimate sustainable way to see this Scottish island

© Rich Hendry Far from the madding crowd: An SUP tour of Skye – Rich Hendry Let me tell you about my favourite spot in Scotland, if I may. When ... Read more »

Australians could face the SACK under tough new Covid vaccine mandate

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Tough new Covid vaccine rules will see tens of thousands of Australians sacked within the next few months because they don’t get the ... Read more »

Maritim tahan bot nelayan tempatan dikendalikan warga Thailand

© Provided by Sinar Harian GEORGETOWN – Agensi Penguatkuasaan Maritim Malaysia (Maritim Malaysia) Pulau Pinang menahan sebuah bot nelayan tempatan yang dikendalikan 14 warga Thailand selepas disyaki melakukan pelbagai kesalahan ... Read more »

Renewed Ethiopia air raids on capital of embattled Tigray region

© Provided by Al Jazeera Ethiopian federal government forces have launched an air raid on Mekelle, the capital of Ethiopia’s embattled Tigray region, for the second time this week. It ... Read more »

Migrant workers in S'pore treated to Saturday lunch of chicken biryani

© Provided by Mothership Disclaimer: Microsoft News is currently reviewing the accuracy of this story with the publisher due to social media source. Updates will be published here if needed. ... Read more »

Next Newcastle manager odds: Paulo Fonseca, Eddie Howe and Frank Lampard linked with job after Steve Bruce exit

© Chelsea FC via Getty Images franklampardeddiehowe20102021A.jpg Paulo Fonseca is the early favourite to succeed Steve Bruce as Newcastle manager. Bruce’s departure from St James’ Park by mutual consent was ... Read more »

SuperJumbo plane to fly half-hour hop from Singapore to Kuala Lumpur

© Getty Images A Singapore Airlines Airbus A380 at Zurich International Airport – Getty Images The world’s biggest passenger plane, the Airbus A380, is to start flying a 184-mile hop ... Read more »

HUAWEI Nova Series: Dynamic smartphone innovation

© Provided by The South African HUAWEI Nova Series: Pure innovation. Picture credit: HUAWEI. If you have not familiarise yourself with the HUAWEI Nova Series yet, you are missing out ... Read more »

21 people, including 10-year old child, miraculously survive Texas plane crash

21 people, including 10-year old child, miraculously survive Texas plane crash – Disclose.tv @disclosetv Our Foreign Staff A private plane crashed when attempting to take off Tuesday in Texas, with ... Read more »

Queen Elizabeth told to rest by doctors - Palace

Britain’s Queen Elizabeth and members of the Royal Family host a reception for international business and investment leaders at Windsor Castle By Guy Faulconbridge and Kate Holton LONDON (Reuters) – ... Read more »

Hartford police investigate shooting after wounded woman shows up at hospital

Hartford police said they are investigating a shooting that wounded a woman early Wednesday. Officers learned about the shooting shortly before 3:30 a.m. when they were dispatched to Saint Francis ... Read more »

Haitian gang asks $1 million ransom for each of the 17 U.S. and Canadian missionaries it kidnapped

The gang that kidnapped 16 American and one Canadian Christian missionaries on Saturday wants $17 million in ransom for their return, Haitian official said Tuesday. “The demand was made to ... Read more »

Start your Christmas shopping now: Amazon launches huge gift sale

All these great Christmas gifts are now on sale. (Getty Images) Yahoo Life's editors are committed to independently selecting wonderful products at great prices for you. We may receive a ... Read more »

Tasmania hold nerve in chase after Siddle and Meredith do the damage

© Getty Images Riley Meredith made a big impact as a concussion substitute © Getty Images Tasmania 252 (Neil-Smith 60, Webster 53*, Cartwright 4-23) and 7 for 217 (Jewell 52, ... Read more »

Fire hits commercial building in Manila

© Luisito Santos tweet Fire hits commercial building in Manila A fire broke out at a commercial building, affecting a nearby bank at UN Avenue in Paco, Manila on Wednesday. ... Read more »

Kerala Assembly adjourned till 25 Oct, pays homage to flood victims

© Provided by The Statesman Kerala Assembly adjourned till 25 Oct, pays homage to flood victims Following the massive downpour in Kerala which claimed 39 lives, the state Assembly paid ... Read more »

Queen cancels trip to Northern Ireland on medical advice

© AFP via Getty Images PRI205864838.jpg The Queen has had to cancel a scheduled trip to Northern Ireland on medical advice, Buckingham Palace has said. The 95-year-old monarch was meant ... Read more »

Aryan Khan, in Custody Since October 3, Denied Bail Again; To Move Bombay HC

© Provided by News18 Aryan Khan, in Custody Since October 3, Denied Bail Again; To Move Bombay HC A special Mumbai court on Wednesday rejected the bail application filed by Aryan ... Read more »

School assemblies cancelled across England due to Covid spike

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Schools across England are cancelling assemblies as Covid continues to rip through classrooms and drive up the national infection rate.  Hundreds of primaries ... Read more »

Punjab Govt Forms SIT to Track Dalit Man's Lynching at Singhu Border

© Provided by News18 Punjab Govt Forms SIT to Track Dalit Man’s Lynching at Singhu Border The Punjab government on Wednesday formed a Special Investigation Team (SIT) to probe the ... Read more »

DMRC starts training the first batch of Dhaka metro

© Provided by The Statesman DMRC starts training the first batch of Dhaka metro The Delhi Metro has commenced the training of its first batch of operations and maintenance staff/officials ... Read more »

Google Pixel 6, Pixel 6 Pro launched: Key specs, top features, sale date and price

Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro The two of the most awaited smartphones of 2021 have arrived. On Tuesday Google introduced the Pixel 6 and the Pixel 6 Pro. One ... Read more »

Nestle India share rises 4% post Q3 earnings

© Provided by Business Today Nestle India share rises 4% post Q3 earnings Nestle India’s shares gained over 4 per cent today after the firm reported a 5 per cent ... Read more »

As Sasikala Tries to Wrest Control of AIADMK, EPS Slams Her for Claiming to be ‘General Secretary'

© Provided by News18 As Sasikala Tries to Wrest Control of AIADMK, EPS Slams Her for Claiming to be ‘General Secretary’ AIADMK Coordinator Edappadi K Palaniswami has lashed out at ... Read more »

India vs Australia, T20 World Cup 2021 Warm-up Match LIVE Cricket Score: Aussies off to a shaky start after opting to bat

© Provided by Firstpost India vs Australia, T20 World Cup 2021 Warm-up Match LIVE Cricket Score: Aussies off to a shaky start after opting to bat 15:52 (IST) After 4 ... Read more »

350 cases of dengue reported in Agra district, highest in a decade

350 cases of dengue reported in Agra district, highest in a decade This year, at least 350 people have been diagnosed with dengue in the Agra district of Uttar Pradesh, ... Read more »

Back to work: Recent retiree job hunting as pension, government benefits come up short

© Darin Morash/CBC Campbell Alexander, a recent Winnipeg retiree, says he’s facing a monthly financial shortfall and is now looking for part-time gigs to get by. Campbell Alexander isn’t living ... Read more »

10 crore Indians due their second Covid-19 vaccine dose are not taking it: Dr VK Paul | Exclusive

National Covid Task Force chief VK Paul expressed concern over the low numbers in the second dose coverage of the Covid-19 vaccination drive, emphasising that more people need to take ... Read more »

Anthem ups 2021 outlook after profit beat on lower costs

(Reuters) -Anthem Inc raised its earnings forecast for 2021 on Wednesday after the second-largest U.S. health insurer beat third-quarter profit estimates on the back of lower-than-expected medical costs. © Reuters/GUS ... Read more »

Aadhaar-PF Linking Must to Get EPF, Insurance. Steps to Link Aadhaar-UAN Online, Offline

© Provided by News18 Aadhaar-PF Linking Must to Get EPF, Insurance. Steps to Link Aadhaar-UAN Online, Offline The Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) had announced that it’s members can avail ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic will need to be vaccinated to play Australian Open: minister

Novak Djokovic will not be able to enter Australia to defend his Australian Open title unless he is fully vaccinated for Covid-19, the country’s immigration minister said on Wednesday, putting ... Read more »

PM Modi inaugurates Kushinagar International Airport, know why it is special

© Provided by DNA Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Wednesday inaugurated an international airport in Uttar Pradesh’s Kushinagar district. It is expected that this will give a big boost to trade ... Read more »

Madras HC reverses acquittal of teacher, sentences him to 10 years imprisonment for assaulting 4-yr-old

Setting aside a trial court order acquitting a school teacher in Puducherry with alleged charges of sexually assaulting a minor student, the Madras High court has now given 10 years ... Read more »

Cricket Australia Rejects ECB's Request to Change Venue of Ashes Opener to Sydney

© Debayan Bhattacharya | India.com Sports Desk Cricket Australia (@Twitter_CricketAus) London, Oct 20: Cricket Australia have rejected England and Wales Cricket Board’s request to move Ashes opener from Brisbane to ... Read more »

Bitcoin Price Today: Bitcoin jumps to near-record high, check Ethereum, Dogecoin prices

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Bitcoin jumped more than 3% to $63,901 on the back of the launch of the first US bitcoin futures-based exchange-traded fund (ETF). The ... Read more »

NEA: Over 800 partially vaccinated diners found at hawker centres in a week

© The Independent Singapore Singapore ― The National Environment Agency (NEA) said on Tuesday (Oct 19) that more than 800 people not fully vaccinated against Covid-19 were found eating at ... Read more »

Abcarian: If you can't save money, time and the planet with Uber and Lyft, then what is the point?

Sunday night, I flew into LAX from San Francisco and boarded a shuttle to the airport’s newish pickup spot for ground transportation just east of Terminal 1. I found myself ... Read more »

Holly Willoughby's favourite mascara is a £14 beauty essential

© David M. Benett – Getty Images Holly Willoughby’s recent instagram post has left swooning over her long lashes. Fear not, we’ve got the secret and it will only set ... Read more »

Students to boycott clubs after reports of women drugged with needles

A student-led campaign group is calling for a nationwide boycott of nightclubs following reports that young women are being drugged with needles on nights out. © AFP via Getty Images ... Read more »