3 Questions: Peko Hosoi on the data-driven reasoning behind MIT's Covid-19 policies for the fall

“We have not played all our cards yet,” says the associate dean of engineering and co-founder of the Isolat modeling group.

Covid-19, Pandemic, Interview, Mechanical engineering, School of Engineering, IDSS, MIT Schwarzman College of Computing, Faculty, Administration, Students, Community, Staff, Data

MIT policies adapted to control the spread of Covid-19 have been informed by modeling efforts from a volunteer group of MIT faculty, students, and postdocs. The collaboration, dubbed Isolat, was co-founded by Anette “Peko” Hosoi, right, the Neil and Jane Pappalardo Professor of Mechanical Engineering and associate dean in the School of Engineering. Image: John Freidah

Covid-19, Pandemic, Interview, Mechanical engineering, School of Engineering, IDSS, MIT Schwarzman College of Computing, Faculty, Administration, Students, Community, Staff, Data

MIT recently re-established policies for indoor masking and has also required weekly testing for people who regularly come to campus — procedures that apply to both vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals. Image: Gretchen Ertl

As students, faculty, and staff prepare for a full return to the MIT campus in the weeks ahead, procedures for entering buildings, navigating classrooms and labs, and interacting with friends and colleagues will likely take some getting used to.

The Institute recently reinforced its policies for indoor masking and has also continued to require regular testing for people who live, work, or study on campus — procedures that apply to both vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals. Vaccination is required for all students, faculty, and staff on campus unless a medical or religious exemption is granted.

These and other policies adopted by MIT to control the spread of Covid-19 have been informed by modeling efforts from a volunteer group of MIT faculty, students, and postdocs. The collaboration, dubbed Isolat, was co-founded by Anette “Peko” Hosoi, the Neil and Jane Pappalardo Professor of Mechanical Engineering and associate dean in the School of Engineering.

The group, which is organized through MIT’s Institute for Data, Systems, and Society (IDSS), has run numerous models to show how measures such as mask wearing, testing, ventilation, and quarantining could affect Covid-19’s spread. These models have helped to shape MIT’s Covid-19 policies throughout the pandemic, including its procedures for returning to campus this fall.

Hosoi spoke with MIT News about the data-backed reasoning behind some of these procedures, including indoor masking and regular testing, and how a “generous community” will help MIT safely weather the virus and its variants.

Q: Take us through how you have been modeling Covid-19 and its variants, in regard to helping MIT shape its Covid policies. What’s the approach you’ve taken, and why?

A: The approach we’re taking uses a simple counting exercise developed in IDSS to estimate the balance of testing, masking, and vaccination that is required to keep the virus in check. The underlying objective is to find infected people faster, on average, than they can infect others, which is captured in a simple algebraic expression. Our objective can be accomplished either by speeding up the rate of finding infected people (i.e. increasing testing frequency) or slowing down the rate of infection (i.e. increasing masking and vaccination) or by a combination of both. To give you a sense of the numbers, balances for different levels of testing are shown in the chart below for a vaccine efficacy of 67 percent and a contagious period of 18 days (which are the CDC’s latest parameters for the Delta variant).

Covid-19, Pandemic, Interview, Mechanical engineering, School of Engineering, IDSS, MIT Schwarzman College of Computing, Faculty, Administration, Students, Community, Staff, Data

The vertical axis shows the now-famous reproduction number R0, i.e. the average number of people that one infected person will infect throughout the course of their illness. These R0 are averages for the population, and in specific circumstances the spreading could be more than that.

Each blue line represents a different testing frequency: Below the line, the virus is controlled; above the line, it spreads. For example, the dotted blue line shows the boundary if we rely solely on vaccination with no testing. In that case, even if everyone is vaccinated, we can only control up to an R0 of about 3.  Unfortunately, the CDC places R0 of the Delta variant somewhere between 5 and 9, so vaccination alone is insufficient to control the spread. (As an aside, this also means that given the efficacy estimates for the current vaccines, herd immunity is not possible.)

Next consider the dashed blue line, which represents the stability boundary if we test everyone once per week. If our vaccination rate is greater than about 90 percent, testing one time per week can control even the CDC’s most pessimistic estimate for the Delta variant’s R0.

Q: In returning to campus over the next few weeks, indoor masking and regular testing are required of every MIT community member, even those who are vaccinated. What in your modeling has shown that each of these policies is necessary?

A: Given that the chart above shows that vaccination and weekly testing are sufficient to control the virus, one should certainly ask “Why have we reinstated indoor masking?” The answer is related to the fact that, as a university, our population turns over once a year; every September we bring in a few thousand new people. Those people are coming from all over the world, and some of them may not have had the opportunity to get vaccinated yet. The good news is that MIT Medical has vaccines and will be administering them to any unvaccinated students as soon as they arrive; the bad news is that, as we all know, it takes three to five weeks for resistance to build up, depending on the vaccine. This means that we should think of August and September as a transition period during which the vaccination rates may fluctuate as new people arrive. 

The other revelation that has informed our policies for September is the recent report from the CDC that infected vaccinated people carry roughly the same viral load as unvaccinated infected people. This suggests that vaccinated people — although they are highly unlikely to get seriously ill — are a consequential part of the transmission chain and can pass the virus along to others. So, in order to avoid giving the virus to people who are not yet fully vaccinated during the transition period, we all need to exercise a little extra care to give the newly vaccinated time for their immune systems to ramp up. 

Q: As the fall progresses, what signs are you looking for that might shift decisions on masking and testing on campus?

A: Eventually we will have to shift responsibility toward individuals rather than institutions, and allow people to make decisions about masks and testing based on their own risk tolerance. The success of the vaccines in suppressing severe illness will enable us to shift to a position in which our objective is not necessarily to control the spread of the virus, but rather to reduce the risk of serious outcomes to an acceptable level. There are many people who believe we need to make this adjustment and wean ourselves off pandemic living. They are right; we cannot continue like this forever. However, we have not played all our cards yet, and, in my opinion, we need to carefully consider what’s left in our hand before we abdicate institutional responsibility.

The final ace we have to play is vaccinating kids. It is important to remember that we have many people in our community with kids who are too young to be vaccinated and, understandably, those parents do not want to bring Covid home to their children. Furthermore, our campus is not just a workplace; it is also home to thousands of people, some of whom have children living in our residences or attending an MIT childcare center. Given that context, and the high probability that a vaccine will be approved for children in the near future, it is my belief that our community has the empathy and fortitude to try to keep the virus in check until parents have the option to protect their children with vaccines. 

Bearing in mind that children constitute an unprotected portion of our population, let me return to the original question and speculate on the fate of masks and testing in the fall. Regarding testing, the analysis suggests that we cannot give that up entirely if we would like to control the spread of the virus. Second, control of the virus is not the only benefit we get from testing. It also gives us situational awareness, serves as an early warning beacon, and provides information that individual members of the community can use as they make decisions about their own risk budget. Personally, I’ve been testing for a year now and I find it easy and reassuring. Honestly, it’s nice to know that I’m Covid-free before I see friends (outside!) or go home to my family.

Regarding masks, there is always uncertainty around whether a new variant will arise or whether vaccine efficacy will fade, but, given the current parameters and our analysis, my hope is that we will be in a position to provide some relief on the mask mandate once the incoming members of our population have been fully vaccinated. I also suspect that whenever the mask mandate is lifted, masks are not likely to go away. There are certainly situations in which I will continue to wear a mask regardless of the mandate, and many in our community will continue to feel safer wearing masks even when they are not required.

I believe that we are a generous community and that we will be willing to take precautions to help keep each other healthy. The students who were on campus last year did an outstanding job, and they have given me a tremendous amount of faith that we can be considerate and good to one another even in extremely trying times.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


PM Modi says 100-crore-vaccine achievement answers doubts about India's capabilities

Prime Minister Narendra Modi. A day after India reached a landmark of 100 crore COVID-19 vaccination jabs, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said that the achievement was because of the efforts ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin Fired Prop Gun That Killed Cinematographer Halyna Hutchins, Injured Director

Alec Baldwin fired a prop gun on a set in New Mexico on Thursday, causing the death of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins and wounding director Joel Souza. The incident occurred on ... Read more »

Ontario's enhanced COVID-19 vaccine certificates with QR codes now in effect

© Government of Ontario Examples of Verify Ontario scan results. Nearly two months after the Ontario government first announced COVID-19 vaccine certificates would be needed for many indoor settings, enhanced ... Read more »

Ada 52 Ribu Kasus Baru Covid-19 di Inggris

© Copyright (c) 2016 TEMPO.CO foto TEMPO.CO, Jakarta – Inggris pada Kamis, 21 Oktober 2021, melaporkan ada 52.009 kasus positif Covid-19. Jumlah itu adalah angka harian virus corona tertinggi di ... Read more »

La Niña expected to bring warmer-than-average winter to parts of U.S.

Climate pattern La Niña is returning for the second year in a row, bringing with it warmer-than-average temperatures and changes in precipitation patterns for many parts of the U.S. this ... Read more »

Prices of Unilever's most popular brands have jumped - and the worst is yet to come

The maker of a host of well known consumer brands has revealed a big lift in prices and warned of worse to come as it battles “unprecedented cost inflation” around ... Read more »

Supreme Court resumes limited physical hearings for first time since March

The SC resumed physical hearings on Thursday, nearly seven months after they were suspended due to the second Covid-19 wave that saw several judges and court staff contracting the infection. ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin Fires Prop Gun on Set, Killing Cinematographer, Injuring Director

Mark Sagliocco/Getty for National Geographic Alec Baldwin cocked and fired a gun meant to be loaded with blanks on the set of a Western movie in Santa Fe on Thursday, ... Read more »

Pemerintah Terbitkan Aturan Perjalanan Baru di Masa Pandemi Covid-19

© Copyright (c) 2016 TEMPO.CO foto TEMPO.CO, Jakarta – Satgas Penanganan Covid-19 mengeluarkan Surat Edaran (SE) Nomor 21 Tahun 2021 tentang Ketentuan Perjalanan Orang Dalam Negeri pada Masa Pandemi Covid-19. ... Read more »

Trick Or Treat! Harry Potter And Toy Story Fans Are Ready For Halloween

It sucks that kids cannot do trick or treat again this year for Halloween. But it hasn’t stopped parents from doing their best. All you have to do is see ... Read more »

Districts with over 5% positivity rate fall to 51 from 55 in October 14-20 week

The number of districts reporting over 5% positivity rate – a criteria used internationally to gauge the Covid-19 spread – have further declined from 55 to 51 in the October ... Read more »

Covid may have killed over 180 thousand health care workers, says WHO

© Maxim Shemetov, REUTERS The WHO said Thursday that 80,000 to 180,000 health care workers may have been killed by Covid-19 up to May this year, insisting they must be prioritised for vaccination. ... Read more »

80% have received at least one dose in 19 of 36 states, UTs

Over 80% population in more than half of the states and union territories has received at least one dose of Covid-19 vaccine. This is more than the national average of ... Read more »

Anak di Bawah 12 Tahun Boleh Naik Kereta Mulai Hari Ini

© Disediakan oleh Katadata PT Kereta Api Indonesia (KAI) kembali memperbolehkan anak-anak berusia di bawah 12 tahun naik kereta api mulai hari ini (22/10), setelah sebelumnya dilarang. Namun, ada beberapa ... Read more »

Canadiens fans welcome Kotkaniemi back to Montreal with boos, vulgar chant

Carolina Hurricanes forward Jesperi Kotkaniemi (82) was not welcomed back to Montreal with open arms. (Eric Bolte-USA TODAY Sports) The Carolina Hurricanes were in Montreal on Thursday night to face ... Read more »

Trans woman forced to flee Malaysia was ‘pinned down and sexually assaulted' by officials

Nur Sajat, a trans social media personality and businesswoman who fled Malaysia, was allegedly sexually assaulted by religious officers. The cosmetics entrepreneur fled the country in January after she was ... Read more »

Pemerintah Gencarkan Vaksinasi Door to Door Demi Tercapai Kekebalan Komunal

© JPNN.COM Pemerintah Gencarkan Vaksinasi Door to Door Demi Tercapai Kekebalan Komunal jpnn.com, JAKARTA – Menteri Komunikasi dan Informatika Johnny G Plate menyampaikan pemerintah menempuh berbagai strategi untuk memperluas cakupan ... Read more »

One of world's last northern white rhinos retired from breeding scheme

Najin is one of two northern white rhinos left in the world Scientists have retired one of the world's last two northern white rhinos from a breeding programme trying to ... Read more »

NASA stacks Orion capsule atop SLS megarocket for Artemis 1 moon mission (video)

© Provided by Space The Orion crew capsule for NASA’s Artemis 1 mission is stacked atop its Space Launch System rocket at Kennedy Space Center on Oct. 20, 2021. NASA ... Read more »

Kemenhub Terbitkan 4 Aturan Terkait Mobilitas Transportasi

© Theofilus Ifan Sucipto Beleid itu untuk meminimalkan penularan covid-19 selama di perjalanan. Jakarta: Kementerian Perhubungan (Kemenhub) menerbitkan sejumlah surat edaran (SE) untuk mengatur pelaku perjalanan di berbagai moda transportasi. Beleid itu ... Read more »

Canada lifts blanket advisory against non-essential travel introduced amid COVID-19

© Credit Image: © Zou Zheng/Xinhua via ZUMA Press Travelers wearing face masks walk through the arrivals hall at Toronto Pearson International Airport in Mississauga, Ontario, Canada, on Sept. 7, ... Read more »

Más de 200 boxeadores mexicanos buscan un lugar en los JCC de San Salvador

Del 26 al 31 de octubre, el Velódromo del Polideportivo Paradero, en Guadalajara, Jalisco, será sede del Campeonato Nacional Elite y el Festival Olímpico de Boxeo 2021, que reunirá a ... Read more »

Quálitas registra nuevo récord de vehículos asegurados, pero siniestralidad va al alza

© Proporcionado por Milenio Quálitas es una de las cuatro aseguradoras que cotizan en Bolsa Mexicana de Valores| Foto: Facebook La compañía Quálitas alcanzó, al cierre del tercer trimestre, un ... Read more »

Rip-off fears as firms charge up to £150 for ‘cheaper' lateral flow travel tests

Luton Airport Covid testing – Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg Half-term holidaymakers are at risk of a new Covid test rip-off as some firms seek to charge up to £150 for the “cheaper” ... Read more »

Gwyneth Paltrow Has Had 'Barely Any Alcohol' This Year as She Prioritizes Health After Having COVID

© Provided by People Pascal Le Segretain/Getty Images Gwyneth Paltrow Gwyneth Paltrow has found a new outlook on her health after a bout with COVID-19 last year. The Academy Award ... Read more »

BoJ Disebut Bakal Hentikan Dukungan Bantuan Pandemi saat Ekonomi Kembali Dibuka

© Angga Bratadharma Beberapa sumber mengatakan Bank of Japan (BoJ) sedang membahas penghapusan program pinjaman covid-19 jika infeksi di Jepang terus berkurang. Tokyo: Beberapa sumber mengatakan Bank of Japan (BoJ) ... Read more »

Merck y Pfizer están desarrollando un antiviral contra el Covid-19

© Proporcionado por Metro Cybernews Desde que comenzó la pandemia del Covid-19 a finales del año 2019, toda la comunidad científica ha volcado sus esfuerzos en búsqueda de distintos tipos ... Read more »

Las caras nuevas de El Clásico: los jugadores que podrían debutar en el Barcelona - Real Madrid

© Getty El Camp Nou será el escenario este domingo de una nueva edición del El Clásico y contará con aficionados para completar la capacidad total del estadio luego de ... Read more »

Top 3 Dunia: Kasus Corona Naik di Cina dan Nasib Veteran Perang Afghanistan

© Copyright (c) 2016 TEMPO.CO foto TEMPO.CO, Jakarta – Berita Top 3 Dunia pada Kamis, 21 Oktober 2021, antara lain tentang kembali naiknya kasus baru harian Covid-19 di Cina hingga ... Read more »

Joan Collins calls William Shatner a ‘fool' for going to space

Joan Collins calls William Shatner a ‘fool’ for going to space Dame Joan Collins has criticised William Shatner after he took a historic flight to space, describing him as a ... Read more »

Contrails: How tweaking flight plans can help the climate

Aircraft condensation trails can have a significant impact on the climate, say researchers Those wispy white lines that crisscross the skies after an aeroplane flies overhead, are far less benign ... Read more »

Cause of Death Revealed for Calif. Family Who Mysteriously Died on Hiking Trail

Authorities have revealed the cause of death for the California family mysteriously found dead with their dog along a hiking trail in the Sierra National Forest in August. In a ... Read more »

App to help people eat better and exercise more will launch next year

A new app helping people to eat better and exercise more will launch next year, the Government has announced. From January 2022, a pilot will see users wearing wrist-worn devices ... Read more »

Mom 'terrified' after spotting suspicious figure in baby monitor footage: 'Search every inch of your house'

A woman spotted something unusual that left her “terrified” while watching her baby monitor footage. TikTok user @honicanlaura shared a video of her young child lying down in her crib ... Read more »

Dame Joan Collins criticises William Shatner over historic space flight

Dame Joan Collins has criticised William Shatner following his historic space flight, describing him as a “fool”. The 90-year-old actor, famed for his Star Trek role as Captain James T ... Read more »

Number of poor Asian Americans in N.Y.C. area up 15 percent in 10 years, study says

The number of Asian Americans living in poverty in metropolitan New York City rose by 15 percent over the past decade, a new report found, including a pronounced increase in ... Read more »

Many double-vaccinated blood cancer patients vulnerable to Covid, study shows

More than half of double-vaccinated blood cancer patients are left without effective protection against coronavirus, new research has found. Data from a trial published in Cancer Cell shows 57% of ... Read more »

Tercera dosis de Pfizer rebasa 95% de efectividad contra el Covid-19 y gana terreno como una opción firme

© Lisa Maree Williams Pfizer y BioNTech tuvieron resultados favorables de una tercera dosis. El refuerzo de la vacuna de Pfizer tiene una efectividad de hasta 95.6% contra el Covid-19, ... Read more »

Meet Starlab: Private space station planned to fly in 2027

Earth orbit may be a hive of commercial activity a few years from now. © Provided by Space An artist’s illustration of the Starlab private space station, a joint project ... Read more »

Brian Laundrie's remains found after monthlong search

Remains found Wednesday during the search for Brian Laundrie, the boyfriend of slain travel blogger Gabby Petito and a person of interest in her death, have been confirmed to belong ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic