26/11 Mumbai terror attack: The need for a culture of remembrance in India

Asia's Tech News Daily

#26/11, #26/11 Mumbai attack, #26/11 rememberance, #history, #memorial, #Remembrance, the poppy, terror attacks, conscription, Partition Museum, Henry Patch, First World War, Two giant blasts, Indian High Commission in London

The poppy, actually an artificial flower pin, is a symbol of remembrance for those who died in the First World War.

In November 2015, an Indian journalist who had flown down from Delhi to cover Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s UK visit asked why several people in London had a red flower (remembrance poppy) on their coats and jackets. Overhearing this, an English lady at the Wembley stadium couldn’t stop herself intervening: “Do you not know, it is for the Remembrance Day.”

The lady knew her history well enough to add that Remembrance Day is marked even in the Commonwealth. It was as much a lesson in history as in the culture of marking historical events. In India, it is usually difficult to imagine both going together. The poppy, actually an artificial flower pin, is a symbol of remembrance for those who died in the First World War. Though it originated in the landscape of the First World War it is worn to commemorate military personnel in later conflicts as well, and used for fundraising.

By wearing the poppy on their clothes, the people get to convey their respect sans state or ceremonial fanfare. The wearing of a poppy is deeply personal, and yet very much part of a collective. Also sold are white poppies, symbolising peace without violence and purple poppies which signify the animals killed in conflict. The poppies are traditionally taken off on Armistice Day (11 November) or on Remembrance (second) Sunday of November, whichever is later.

Also read: Mumbai 26/11 terror attack: Tributes pour in for martyrs on 13th anniversary

When ten terrorists travelling from Pakistan carried out the horrific and synchronised terror attack in Mumbai in November 2008, it brought out the chinks in our security armour. Now, 13 years later, it has also exposed our collective failure to suitably memorialise the attack. An attack of such a magnitude could have been used as a focal point to illustrate the multiple bombings, violence and terror attacks that urban India has faced.

It was not India’s 9/11, it was India’s 26/11. Mumbai is India’s financial capital and also the country’s most cosmopolitan city. During colonial times the city was also the biggest site of indigenous capitalism. The horrendous attack was an assault on the psyche of modern India, as the city was converted into a conflict-ridden border outpost. Nationals of sixteen countries were among the 166 killed, while the assailants took orders from their handlers in Pakistan.

From the archives: 26/11 Mumbai attack survivor Moshe Holtzberg turns 11, set to visit Nariman House

Yet apart from few functions in some resident associations and by political/social organisations, the 26/11 memorial being visited by the Governor and ministers, and dwindling focus in the media with each passing year, there is no commemoration of the attack that makes it likely it would hold the imagination of the people in the near future. Driven by the never-give-up stance, and the city never sleeps mode, it seems the gruesome reality of this attack will be a likely casualty of memory, overtaken by dreams of Bollywood, big money, and social mobility that the city offers.

But if Remembrance Day could take root in Britain where conscription deeply divided the country, and was only grudgingly passed by the Parliament at the height of war, why can’t the 2008 Mumbai terror attack spawn its own Remembrance Day in India?

It is beyond the remit of this column to explain the reasons, but the general apathy to history and a reluctance to openly deal with violence and tragedies could be a starting point. How do we explain that the country’s first Partition Museum came into existence decades after its occurrence, when the numbers of those directly affected dwindled drastically, leaving so much undocumented?

Also read: India asks Pakistan to expedite trial in 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks case

In 2009, when Henry Patch, the last surviving combat soldier of the First World War, died aged 111 years, there was a collective sigh in Britain that the First World War had passed from living memory into history. But Remembrance Day services and the wearing of poppy has ensured that it will continue to live in the collective memory of the nation.

Yes, 26/11 was no world war, but neither was 9/11. But both marked the fruition of terror templates that mocked the world order. The latter did lead to a so-called war on terror, leaving a problematic legacy; but the former it seems apart from relooking at security aspects and diplomatic manoeuvrings, will turn a pale reminder of the horrendous tragedy much before the case even finds a closure.

The ten terrorists, to inflict terror, arrived in inflatable dinghies taking the Karachi-Mumbai Sea route that was once a busy civilian and commercial transport route. In 1944, a freighter SS Fort Stikine that took the same route had reached Bombay (now Mumbai) on April 14, after its last stop at Karachi on April 9. On April 14, it caught fire at Victoria dock while waiting to be unloaded of its cargo, which included gold, cotton and explosives, among other things. Two giant blasts killed over 1,000 and 3,000 people were injured. The impact of the blast was felt in different parts of the city. It’s now reduced to occasional stories on how once gold rained in Bombay! Meanwhile, children in Britain continue to learn about the 1666 Great Fire of London.

Also the 26/11 terror attacks must provide the many victims – both local and international, and many others who have over the years moved locations and lived with physical and mental scars, an avenue to express their grief. A panel discussion organised by the Indian High Commission in London to remember the martyrs of 26/11, provided some a platform to share their experiences and others to join in, but also highlighted the dearth of avenues to do so.

A simple pin, India’s very own symbol of Remembrance, could go a long way in creating a culture where everyone – survivors and victim’s families, politicians and commoners, old and young, Indians and foreigners – can find an outlet to express their collective grief and keep the memory and history of 26/11 alive.

Also read: Indians in Israel remember 26/11 Mumbai terror attack, demand action against masterminds

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Adalia Williams, social media star with Benjamin Button syndrome, dies at 15

Adalia Rose Williams suffered from real-life Benjamin Button disease since she was three months old. (Image credit: Willams’s Instagram account) Adalia Rose Williams, a US teen battling the Benjamin Button syndrome, ... Read more »

Indomitable spirit: A glimpse into the life and career of ex-SBI chairperson Arundhati Bhattacharya

(File) Arundhati Bhattacharya was the chairperson of State Bank of India from October 2013 to October 2017. An autobiographical work, Indomitable: A Working Woman’s Notes on Work, Life and Leadership is the ... Read more »

U-19 World Cup: India beat South Africa by 45 runs; start campaign on winning note

Representative Image (Unsplash) Four-time champions India dished out a clinical show to start their U-19 World Cup campaign on a winning note, thrashing South Africa by 45 runs in Georgetown. ... Read more »

The mainstreaming of cuss words

At the end of the popular HBO series Succession, Siobhan “Shiv” Roy sums up the thwarted ambitions of the siblings against their father Logan Roy with the words “Mum f***** ... Read more »

Review: 'Alphabetica' tells us as much about ABC as the dangers of majoritarianism

(Representational image) In certain passages in the book, you can almost hear the rhythm of the typewriter keys ‘hitting the Ink Ribbon’. Nothing is as simple as ABC for much ... Read more »

The book that inspired photographer Annie Leibovitz's career

Annie Leibovitz at an event in 2015. (Image: Franz Johann Morgenbesser via Wikimedia Commons 2.0; cropped) Henri Cartier Bresson’s evocative photographs are known around the world. One of his books ... Read more »

Healing Space | How to stop issuing fake apologies

Not all apologies are welcome; some can leave a situation worse than it was to begin with. (Illustration by Suneesh K.) Note to readers: Healing Space is a weekly series that helps ... Read more »

What does Goa's new voter want?

Of the over 11.56 lakh people eligible to vote in the 2022 Goa Assembly election, 30,599 are first-time voters. December 9, 1963. That day 59 years ago, 2,60,372 Goans walked ... Read more »

One-month-old baby in Delhi recovers from COVID-19, discharged from hospital

The baby was admitted to Moolchand Hospital’s newborn intensive care unit. (Screengrab from video tweeted by @Moolchand_Hosp) A one-month-old Covid-positive baby, admitted to a hospital in Delhi, has been discharged ... Read more »

Videos: Huge volcanic eruption triggers Tsunami in Tonga, alarm sounded across South Pacific

Tonga volcano: The initial eruption lasted at least eight minutes and sent plumes of gas, ash and smoke several kilometres into the air. (Credit: NWS Honolulu Twitter) Frightened Tongans fled ... Read more »

Siddharth Sengupta on 'Yeh Kaali Kaali Aankhein': "Television is too conservative for a story like this"

Tahir Raj Bhasin and Shweta Tripathi in ‘Yeh Kaali Kaali Aankhen’. Fresh off the success of 83, in which he played Sunil Gavaskar, Tahir Raj Bhasin is now looking forward ... Read more »

Look who's riding electric bikes in Bengaluru

Yulu estimates that 17,000 gig workers have used their electric cycles in 2021. The company even designed an electric vehicle with a goods carrier that can carry about 10 kg ... Read more »

In photos: India marks Army Day 2022 with parade, tributes to soldiers

Army chief General Manoj Mukund Naravane, Air Chief Marshal VR Chaudhari and Admiral R Hari Kumar of the Indian Navy pay tributes to martyrs at the National War Memorial in ... Read more »

Review: 'Outlast' offers counsel to businesses starting out on their ESG journeys

Improvement on ESG metrics can mean businesses use resources more efficiently, lower cost of operations, and reduce risks, write the authors. Gone are the days when ‘sustainability’ was seen as ... Read more »

Indian-origin professor Soumitra Dutta appointed dean of Oxford's business school, Anand Mahindra, others congratulate him

Soumitra Dutta has helped several governments in formulating technology and innovation policies. Soumitra Dutta, a renowned professor of Indian origin, has been appointed the dean of the Saïd Business School ... Read more »

Instant guide to gourmet pizza

(Representational image) Pizza started out as a simple peasant dish of bread and tomato sauce in Italy. Today, there is a dizzying array of styles, crusts, toppings. Free pizza is ... Read more »

Armaan Malik: "English pop music is going to run parallel with my Bollywood and regional music"

Singer-songwriter Armaan Malik. Armaan Malik recently dropped his fourth English solo track ‘You’. The 26-year-old singer-songwriter who sings in a dozen different languages, became the first artist to top the ... Read more »

The first Tamil phrase Anand Mahindra learnt while in school

Anand Mahindra said that he has used “poda dei”, which translates to “go away”, many times. “Sometimes loudly, but usually under my breath,” he added. Industrialist Anand Mahindra, in tweet ... Read more »

Clap, don't chant: China aims for 'Zero COVID' Olympics

File image of preparations for the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics (Image Source: AP) Athletes will need to be vaccinated or face a long quarantine take tests daily and wear masks ... Read more »

EXPLAINER: How Novak Djokovic plans to fight deportation in court

Following the annulment of this visa, Novak Djokovic could face possible deportation from Australia, ending his chances to win the 21st major title at the upcoming Australian Open tournament. Novak ... Read more »

The Tippling Point | The tequila that shot to dizzying heights

Jose Cuervo Tradicional is made with 100% agave while Especial Silver and Gold are mixto – only 51% of the alcohol comes from agave. “Jose Cuervo you are a friend ... Read more »

Hitachi's Rich Legacy in India

Moneycontrol journalists were not involved in the creation of this content. Read more »

Day after Groww, Zerodha app down for many users during trading hours

Twitter users suggested that Zerodha improve its servers. Many users of stock brokerage platform Zerodha faced troubles with the application on Friday and took to Twitter to voice their grievances. ... Read more »

Dogecoin value jumps after Elon Musk tweets it can be used to buy Tesla merchandise

Elon Musk has said when it comes to transactions per day, Dogecoin is a better currency than Bitcoin. A five-word tweet by billionaire Elon Musk led to a mcryptocurrencyassive jump ... Read more »

When Ratan Tata met Guns N' Roses star Slash at Jaguar outlet

Ratan Tata met Slash of Guns N’ Roses at a Jaguar store in California. (Image credit: Photo Instagrammed by ratantata) Industrialist Ratan Tata on Friday recalled his meeting with Slash, ... Read more »

Review: Yeh Kaali Kaali Aankhen has all the trappings of '90s Bollywood pulp, but lacks cinematic breadth and feel

Tahir Raj Bhasin and Anchal Singh in ‘Yeh Kaali Kaali Aankhen’. In form, Sidharth Sengupta’s Yeh Kaali Kaali Aankhen assuredly returns to 1990s’ Bollywood pulp in certain ways—scenes are treated ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic could face deportation as visa cancelled for the second time ahead of Australian Open

Following the annulment of this visa, Novak Djokovic could face possible deportation from Australia, ending his chances to win the 21st major title at the upcoming Australian Open tournament. The ... Read more »

Redmi Note 11S design leaks, could feature 108MP camera from Xiaomi 11i HyperCharge

Redmi Note 11S price in India is expected to be around Rs 17,000. Redmi Note 11S design renders have leaked online. The upcoming smartphone is expected to be priced at ... Read more »

'Bachpan ka Pyaar' boy Sahdev Dirdo, 10, to launch NFT collection

Sahdev Dirdo’s viral “Bachpan ka Pyaar” clip was shot by his teacher nearly two years ago. (Image credit: Photo Instagrammed by noften_nft) Sahdev Dirdo, the 10-year-old who gained internet fame ... Read more »

Singer Ronnie Spector, best known for 'Be My Baby', dies after battle with cancer

Ronnie Spector died after a brief battle with cancer. Ronnie Spector — the cat-eyed rock ‘n’ roll singer who fronted the 1960s group the Ronettes, whose era-defining hits included the ... Read more »

Kylie Jenner beats Ariana Grande to become most followed woman on Instagram, crosses 300 million followers

Kylie Jenner is pregnant with her second child with partner, rapper Travis Scott. With over 300 million followers, makeup mogul and social media personality Kylie Jenner is now the most-followed ... Read more »

On Jeff Bezos' birthday, throwback photos from partner Lauren Sanchez and a note on what the world doesn't see

Amazon boss Jeff Bezos’ girlfriend Lauren Sanchez posted a photo montage capturing his journey from being a child having fun to the billionaire boss that he is today. (Screengrab from ... Read more »

OnePlus 9RT launch in India today at 5 PM: Check leaked price, specifications

OnePlus 9RT specifications include a Snapdragon 888 SoC, a 4500 mAh battery with 65W fast charging. OnePlus 9RT launch in India is set to take place at 5 PM IST ... Read more »

Page from 1984 Spider-Man comic auctioned at record $3.36 million.

The auction of the page from the Spider-Man comic book took place in Dallas on January 13. (Image posted on Instagram by Heritage Auctions) A single page of artwork from ... Read more »

Wordle fans are downloading like crazy another app by the same name

Steven Cravotta created an app called “Wordle!” when he was 18. As Wordle, the five-letter online word game continues to be a global rage, a US-based marketing coordinator noticed that ... Read more »

Anand Mahindra wants to wish Indians on ‘each and every' harvest festival. Seeks Twitter's help

“Each year I miss out on one of them,” Anand Mahindra said about harvest festivals in India. Industrialist Anand Mahindra on Thursday asked his Twitter followers for a definitive list ... Read more »

OnePlus 9RT India launch event today at 5 PM: Where to watch the livestream

OnePlus 9RT specifications include a Snapdragon 888 SoC, a 4500 mAh battery with 65W fast charging. OnePlus 9RT launch in India is scheduled to begin at 5 PM local time. ... Read more »

OnePlus 9RT India price, specifications announced; available during Amazon Great Indian Republic Day Sale

OnePlus 9RT specifications include a Snapdragon 888 SoC, a 4500 mAh battery with 65W fast charging. OnePlus 9RT launched in India is the latest premium smartphone from the Oppo sub-brand. ... Read more »

'Then Polo, now Dolo': 7 paracetamol memes we could relate to

One of the Dolo-650 memes that has been doing rounds in Twitter. Between the third wave and flu doing rounds in the country, there is hardly anyone who does not ... Read more »

Storyboard18 | Ads hurting religious sentiments, mocking men offend Indians: report

Among the ads deemed offensive were those that seemingly provoked children’s interest in ‘adult life’, particularly in the idea of sexuality and physical intimacy. Months after advertisements for Fem Bleach, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic